{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp03_full320_20260801","cell_id":"computability_boundary_mapping__biology_ecology","trajectory_id":"R","attempt_index":0,"candidate_sha256":"4ba5a6a9bccaeafc564fa9d7812b500bb5beaeb4d47b4bc486c2d90b436dc3a0","gates":{"G1":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The ecological forecasting problem is independently specified through actors, observable status collapse, consequences, objectives, and a falsifier that does not presuppose the proposed intervention."},"G2":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The transfer preserves the open-ended class, universal terminating guarantee, model-relative boundary, proof obligations, enforceable restrictions, and honest fallback structure without treating ecosystems themselves as literal programs."},"G3":{"status":"PASS","reason":"Formal classification, checked constructive or impossibility evidence, enforceable fragments, guarantee-aware routing, and explicit unresolved states plausibly interrupt the identified path from simulation behavior to false ecological certainty."},"G4":{"status":"PASS","reason":"Every archetype component has a domain realization, load-bearing mechanisms have distinct causal roles, rejected mechanisms have coherent reasons, and the proposal does not make artifacts or reviewers substitute for mathematical evidence."},"G5":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The unrestricted result, domain prevalence, and ecological encoding are explicitly bounded as hypotheses; no timeout, analogy, or unfinished reduction is presented as proof."},"G6":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The packet separately falsifies the claimed problem through a bounded known-solvable requirement and the intervention through solver error, abstraction unsoundness, failed preservation, or downstream misuse of unresolved outputs."},"G7":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The first test is confined to synthetic models, formal and ecological authority are separated, field action is excluded, affected parties are named, and concrete halt and guarantee-withdrawal conditions are provided."}},"scores":{"structural_fit":{"score":4,"reason":"The candidate closely reproduces the archetype's quantifier, representation, computation-model, proof-boundary, restriction, and fallback relationships."},"domain_fidelity":{"score":3,"reason":"The proposal meaningfully incorporates ecological model families, stochasticity, numerical precision, model-reality gaps, conservation authority, and ecological outcome semantics, while acknowledging that formal relevance remains to be established."},"causal_plausibility":{"score":3,"reason":"The chain can prevent unsupported universal forecasts and status collapse, although its value for ecology depends on successfully formalizing a useful outcome predicate and model class."},"component_translation":{"score":4,"reason":"The component map is complete, domain-adapted where needed, and linked coherently to the mechanism dispositions and causal chain."},"adversarial_survival":{"score":4,"reason":"The candidate directly confronts bounded practical tasks, semantic mismatch between models and nature, failed reduction preservation, unusable fragments, abstraction unsoundness, and downstream suppression of unresolved results."},"reframing_gain":{"score":4,"reason":"It separates computability from statistical uncertainty and scaling, while replacing unconditional ecological labels with model-relative guarantees and governed fallback states."},"practicality_testability":{"score":3,"reason":"The synthetic finite-state comparison, exhaustive reference results, routing behavior, proof review, and halt conditions form a credible initial test, though formal predicates and acceptance thresholds still require specification."},"expected_value_risk":{"score":3,"reason":"Early boundary testing could avert false certainty and wasted engineering effort, and the restricted pilot limits direct ecological harm, but formal authority and narrow-fragment misuse remain material risks."},"novelty_evidence":{"score":0,"reason":"Prior art is explicitly unsearched and the packet supplies no comparative evidence supporting novelty."}},"weighted_total":83.75,"disposition":"DEEP_RESEARCH","fabrication_findings":[],"weak_dimensions":["novelty_evidence"],"actionable_critique":[{"priority":"HIGH","issue":"The ecological outcome predicate and unrestricted modeling language remain conceptual rather than formally instantiated.","repair":"Define executable syntax and semantics for a scientifically useful pilot language, formalize each long-run outcome, and demonstrate that fragment membership and routing are mechanically decidable.","evidence_boundary":"The packet supplies a proposed mapping and test setting but no completed ecological formalization."},{"priority":"MEDIUM","issue":"The impossibility route has not yet discharged its preservation obligations.","repair":"Either produce an independently checked encoding with explicit totality, computability, and predicate preservation, or retain the unrestricted status as unresolved and evaluate only the constructive restricted branch.","evidence_boundary":"No completed reduction or impossibility certificate is included."},{"priority":"MEDIUM","issue":"Novelty is unsupported.","repair":"Compare the proposal with existing work on verification of ecological models, dynamical-system reachability, population-process analysis, and formal decision support before making a novelty claim.","evidence_boundary":"The candidate explicitly records prior art as unsearched."}],"repairs":[],"improvement_attribution":{"kind":"NONE","reason":"This is the original attempt, with no prior problem identifier, causal-lever identifier, or addressed repair from which improvement could be attributed."},"trajectory_replacement":false,"arm_guess":"MECHANISM_PACKET","recommendation":"SUCCESS","tester_summary":"The candidate is a strong, safely bounded structural transfer with a coherent mechanism stack, complete component mapping, falsifiable synthetic pilot, and explicit restraint around unproved ecological undecidability. Its main unresolved work is formal instantiation and external novelty research, neither of which is misrepresented as completed evidence."}