{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp03_full320_20260801","cell_id":"computability_boundary_mapping__film_media_production","trajectory_id":"R","attempt_index":0,"candidate_sha256":"f806caf5a3718041e36421fc90ea09b4b21594e3cab24ff4b15d75323aeb2d67","gates":{"G1":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The candidate identifies an independently recognizable pipeline problem: unrestricted completion preflight, binary treatment of timeout and uncertainty, and resulting scheduling and compute-allocation harms."},"G2":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The transfer preserves the archetype's unrestricted class claim, explicit representation and computation model, constructive-versus-impossibility inquiry, enforceable decidable fragment, honest fallback, and reclassification triggers."},"G3":{"status":"PASS","reason":"Mechanical fragment admission, checked exact analysis within that fragment, guarantee-labeled fallback routing, and distinct uncertainty outputs directly target the mechanisms producing false clearance, false rejection, and overbroad delivery claims."},"G4":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The component map is complete and domain-translated, while the selected mechanisms have differentiated causal, operational, review, safety, and test roles without treating records or checklists as proofs."},"G5":{"status":"PASS","reason":"Domain assumptions and expected effects are explicitly bounded as hypotheses or inferences; the candidate does not claim that undecidability, effectiveness, or novelty has already been established."},"G6":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The problem can be falsified by an audit showing a finite total production language with no truth-valued timeout misuse, while the intervention has separate bounded-pilot failure criteria covering comparative outcomes and exact-checker correctness."},"G7":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The first step is synthetic and offline, authority for production changes is separately assigned, untrusted execution is sandboxed, live delivery decisions are excluded, and explicit halt and rollback conditions are provided."}},"scores":{"structural_fit":{"score":4,"reason":"The proposal closely instantiates computability-boundary mapping rather than merely borrowing its vocabulary."},"domain_fidelity":{"score":4,"reason":"Render graphs, plug-ins, scripts, assets, frame bounds, worker semantics, preflight practices, and production authority are coherently integrated into the film-production setting."},"causal_plausibility":{"score":3,"reason":"The intervention acts on the relevant guarantee and routing failures, although its claimed operational benefit remains a pilot hypothesis."},"component_translation":{"score":4,"reason":"All major components receive concrete pipeline realizations, and their dependencies are reflected in the causal chain."},"adversarial_survival":{"score":4,"reason":"The candidate directly tests the strongest anti-signature, reduction-model mismatch, semantic instability, unenforceable fragment membership, and adverse pilot outcomes."},"reframing_gain":{"score":4,"reason":"It usefully separates computability, bounded evidence, practical complexity, and operational reliability in a setting otherwise prone to collapsing them into binary preflight."},"practicality_testability":{"score":3,"reason":"The offline corpus, fixed limits, oracle cases, exact-verdict check, and rollback make a credible pilot, but outcome measurement and the semantics of successful completion need further operational precision."},"expected_value_risk":{"score":4,"reason":"The proposed pilot can expose specification errors before production commitment while tightly limiting execution, authority, and delivery risk."},"novelty_evidence":{"score":0,"reason":"Prior art is explicitly unsearched, so no closed-book novelty evidence is available."}},"weighted_total":88.75,"disposition":"DEEP_RESEARCH","fabrication_findings":[],"weak_dimensions":["causal_plausibility","practicality_testability","novelty_evidence"],"actionable_critique":[{"priority":"MEDIUM","issue":"The operational meaning of successful completion is not yet fixed tightly enough to exclude disputes involving crashes, corrupt assets, nondeterministic services, or unacceptable output.","repair":"Before deployment research, define a versioned observable completion predicate and show that the restricted checker proves that same predicate under the registered execution model.","evidence_boundary":"The candidate itself identifies semantic instability and omitted failure modes; it supplies no validated production predicate."},{"priority":"MEDIUM","issue":"Comparative pilot outcomes are named but their labeling and measurement protocol are underspecified.","repair":"Pre-register corpus construction, ground-truth adjudication, baseline interpretation rules, resource limits, and outcome measures for false clearance, false rejection, uncontrolled compute, and UNKNOWN handling.","evidence_boundary":"Operational benefit is presented as a hypothesis and has not been empirically demonstrated."},{"priority":"LOW","issue":"Novelty relative to existing render-farm verification, workflow-language restriction, and static-analysis practice is unknown.","repair":"Conduct a bounded prior-art review and identify which elements are established practice versus a distinct integration or governance contribution.","evidence_boundary":"The supplied record explicitly marks prior art as unsearched."}],"repairs":[],"improvement_attribution":{"kind":"NONE","reason":"This is an original attempt with no prior problem or causal-lever identifier and no claimed revision; remaining weaknesses concern validation and operational specification rather than attributable improvement."},"trajectory_replacement":false,"arm_guess":"MECHANISM_PACKET","recommendation":"SUCCESS","tester_summary":"The candidate is a strong, safety-bounded transfer that preserves the archetype's formal boundary logic and translates it credibly into render-pipeline operations. Its main residue is empirical and operational: the completion predicate, comparative measurement protocol, and prior-art position remain to be established."}