{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp03_full320_20260801","cell_id":"computability_boundary_mapping__music_musicology","trajectory_id":"R","attempt_index":0,"candidate_sha256":"5fbb63e7b01a03f3b2c2b1dd7910cbcc9e1279386c75b2cca2ee77fe0e0ddef5","gates":{"G1":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The operational failure is independently recognizable: timeout or exhaustion is converted into absence while an unrestricted total guarantee is asserted."},"G2":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The proposal faithfully maps an open-ended encoded class, universal quantification, model-relative impossibility, enforceable decidable regions, and honest weaker fallbacks."},"G3":{"status":"RESEARCH_NEEDED","reason":"The causal chain is coherent conditionally, but the declared language's computational expressiveness and the answer-preserving source-to-score construction remain unproved."},"G4":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The component map is complete, mechanism roles are differentiated, rejected mechanisms have defensible rationales, and the selected mechanisms preserve their stated guarantees."},"G5":{"status":"PASS","reason":"Unverified claims are explicitly labeled as hypotheses, prior art is marked unsearched, and no theorem or domain fact is presented as established evidence."},"G6":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The problem and intervention have distinct falsifiers covering a bounded or total actual class, a failed reduction, unenforceable fragment membership, and an independently checked full decider."},"G7":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The first test is offline and reversible, authority over musical meaning remains with authors, deceptive outputs are excluded, and explicit halt and rollback conditions are supplied."}},"scores":{"structural_fit":{"score":4,"reason":"The candidate closely instantiates the archetype's universal-decision boundary, model contract, restricted regions, status lattice, and governed fallback structure."},"domain_fidelity":{"score":3,"reason":"Executable scores, interpreters, event streams, motif encodings, and catalog consequences are credible domain objects, while the proposal correctly excludes broader claims about musical meaning."},"causal_plausibility":{"score":3,"reason":"A valid halting-preserving encoding would justify the boundary, and fragment enforcement plus labeled routing would directly prevent deceptive Boolean outputs; the key formal premise is still conditional."},"component_translation":{"score":4,"reason":"Every required component receives a concrete music-domain realization, with especially clear translations for representation, semantics, proof obligations, unknown states, scope enforcement, and reclassification triggers."},"adversarial_survival":{"score":4,"reason":"The candidate identifies the strongest neighboring explanation, limits the claim to formal event reachability, and supplies decisive counterevidence and intervention failure conditions."},"reframing_gain":{"score":4,"reason":"It replaces an undifferentiated analyzer request with a model-relative classification and separates eventual reachability, bounded reachability, recognition, abstraction, and unknown outcomes."},"practicality_testability":{"score":3,"reason":"The shadow test, routing modes, rollback conditions, and fragment enforcement are operationally testable, but exact execution awaits a specified language, checked reduction, and certified fragment analyzer."},"expected_value_risk":{"score":3,"reason":"The reversible first step can prevent false classifications and wasted implementation effort, while identified risks are bounded through labels, quarantine, review, and withdrawal of unsupported guarantees."},"novelty_evidence":{"score":0,"reason":"Prior art is explicitly unsearched, so no novelty conclusion has evidentiary support."}},"weighted_total":83.75,"disposition":"RESEARCH_NEEDED","fabrication_findings":[],"weak_dimensions":["causal_plausibility","novelty_evidence"],"actionable_critique":[{"priority":"HIGH","issue":"The unrestricted impossibility boundary depends on an unnamed score language and an unverified halting-preserving encoding.","repair":"Fix the language and interpreter semantics, exhibit the total computable translation, prove the reachability biconditional, and obtain independent checking.","evidence_boundary":"Until those obligations are discharged, undecidability is a conditional hypothesis rather than a deployable classification."},{"priority":"HIGH","issue":"The exact-answer region is described by examples but lacks an enforceable grammar and a certified total analyzer.","repair":"Publish a versioned fragment grammar, mechanical membership check, analyzer, correctness proof, and termination proof.","evidence_boundary":"Bounded simulations or successful examples cannot establish class-wide totality or correctness."},{"priority":"MEDIUM","issue":"No evidence supports novelty or distinguishes the proposal from existing generative-music verification practice.","repair":"Conduct scoped prior-art research only after the formal problem and guarantees are fixed.","evidence_boundary":"The unsearched status supports no claim of originality."}],"repairs":[{"repair_id":"formal_reduction_certificate","target":"Unrestricted score-event reachability classification","operation_code":"REPAIR_CAUSAL_CHAIN","affected_identifiers":["halting_problem_reduction","universal_generative_score_motif_reachability"],"acceptance_test":"An independent checker verifies a total computable source-to-score map for the declared language and proves that the target event is emitted if and only if the source computation halts.","materially_distinct":true,"supersedes":null,"repair_fingerprint":"9fdc97b2b687a9a9cd25732f9d2160fd83fd7c662dd14b88509d6093a3d788b4"},{"repair_id":"certified_score_fragment","target":"Enforceable decidable score fragment","operation_code":"COMPLETE_COMPONENTS","affected_identifiers":["constructive_algorithm_and_correctness_proof","enforceable_score_fragment_with_labeled_fallbacks","language_fragment_restriction"],"acceptance_test":"A versioned grammar mechanically rejects every out-of-fragment score, and an independently checked analyzer terminates with the correct reachability verdict for every admitted score.","materially_distinct":true,"supersedes":null,"repair_fingerprint":"444776536ce62e33c8446ba4d8cf35b6a4ed8ccc61614f30a3fa3bb723676ae1"}],"improvement_attribution":{"kind":"NONE","reason":"This is an original attempt with unchanged problem and causal-lever identifiers, no prior repairs, and no demonstrated trajectory improvement to attribute."},"trajectory_replacement":false,"arm_guess":"MECHANISM_PACKET","recommendation":"RESEARCH_NEEDED","tester_summary":"This is a strong, domain-bounded structural transfer with honest uncertainty, complete components, useful falsifiers, and safe operational fallbacks. Its central impossibility classification and exact restricted region remain conditional on formal artifacts that are not present in the closed-book packet."}