{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp03_full320_20260801","cell_id":"invariant_mode_decomposition_design__statistics_experimental_design","trajectory_id":"R","attempt_index":0,"candidate_sha256":"b65e7e5e913d1f4370f7e0fd3fb59b86b84f5e12603ef55a45eab36e8f55dbb5","gates":{"G1":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The repeated-process problem is independently recognizable in experimental-design terms: marginally acceptable settings can conceal persistent multivariate response dynamics."},"G2":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The fitted transition operator, joint response directions, persistence spectrum, modal contrasts, residual checks, and drift limits preserve the archetype's core relations rather than merely borrowing spectral vocabulary."},"G3":{"status":"PASS","reason":"Randomized controls enter through the estimated control-response map, and the proposed allocation targets reachable modes whose persistence and risk-weighted sensitivity make them consequential. Comparative leverage remains explicitly falsifiable against the original-coordinate rival."},"G4":{"status":"PASS","reason":"All named components receive domain realizations, and the selected mechanisms have differentiated causal, testing, operational, and guardrail roles. Rejected mechanisms are excluded for reasons consistent with their scope."},"G5":{"status":"PASS","reason":"Empirical advantage and causal interpretation are bounded as hypotheses, prior-art status is disclosed as unsearched, and descriptive modes are not presented as physical causes. No unsupported result or fabricated authority is asserted."},"G6":{"status":"PASS","reason":"The problem falsifier tests whether consequential cross-coordinate dynamics exist, while the intervention falsifier separately tests whether modal-risk allocation improves detection or precision over the nearest rival."},"G7":{"status":"PASS","reason":"Decision authority, certified operating limits, product quarantine, stopping conditions, rollback, and prohibited interpretations are explicit and appropriately assigned."}},"scores":{"structural_fit":{"score":4,"reason":"The proposal translates the full transformation-to-mode-to-action-to-residual structure with strong traceability."},"domain_fidelity":{"score":3,"reason":"The state-space, randomization, rival-design, held-out validation, and error-inflation concerns are statistically appropriate, although estimability depends on unspecified outcome and control dimensions."},"causal_plausibility":{"score":3,"reason":"Randomization and reachability through the control-response map support the causal test, but the promised precision gain depends on selection stability and adequate separation of discovery from confirmation."},"component_translation":{"score":4,"reason":"Every archetype component has a concrete experimental-design realization, including coupling, scope, residual, drift, and spectral-gap safeguards."},"adversarial_survival":{"score":4,"reason":"The candidate names a strong original-coordinate rival, a substantive analogy break, distinct falsifiers, reachability failure, non-normality, and adaptive-selection risk."},"reframing_gain":{"score":4,"reason":"It changes the design target from isolated settings and marginal endpoints to reachable, persistent joint-response directions with explicit risk relevance."},"practicality_testability":{"score":3,"reason":"The bounded randomized comparison, held-out observations, stopping rules, and rival are executable, but power and identifiability specifications remain to be preregistered."},"expected_value_risk":{"score":3,"reason":"Potential earlier detection of persistent joint drift is valuable, and operating risks are strongly bounded, though comparative benefit has not yet been demonstrated."},"novelty_evidence":{"score":0,"reason":"Prior art is expressly unsearched and no evidence of novelty is supplied."}},"weighted_total":83.75,"disposition":"DEEP_RESEARCH","fabrication_findings":[],"weak_dimensions":["novelty_evidence"],"actionable_critique":[{"priority":"HIGH","issue":"The pilot size is fixed without specifying state dimension, control dimension, lag order, anticipated effect sizes, or the estimability of the transition and control-response matrices.","repair":"Preregister a simulation-based operating-characteristic analysis covering matrix recovery, mode-selection stability, persistent-risk contrast precision, and the discovery-confirmation split under the intended dimensions.","evidence_boundary":"The comparative precision advantage remains a testable hypothesis until those operating characteristics and pilot results are available."},{"priority":"MEDIUM","issue":"Eigenvalue-based stability can miss consequential finite-horizon amplification from a non-normal transition operator.","repair":"Add a preregistered transient-amplification diagnostic and require either acceptable finite-horizon gain or explicit inclusion of the amplified directions in allocation and monitoring.","evidence_boundary":"Recording non-normality identifies the hazard but does not establish that the proposed contrasts control it."},{"priority":"MEDIUM","issue":"Safety-weighted outcome priorities may be disputed or may materially alter which modes receive experimental effort.","repair":"Predeclare weight ownership, perform sensitivity analysis across defensible weight sets, and report whether allocation conclusions remain stable.","evidence_boundary":"No evidence is supplied that the proposed weighting represents an accepted stakeholder utility function."}],"repairs":[],"improvement_attribution":{"kind":"NONE","reason":"This is an original attempt with no prior repair record and no change to either the problem identifier or causal-lever identifier."},"trajectory_replacement":false,"arm_guess":"MECHANISM_PACKET","recommendation":"SUCCESS","tester_summary":"The candidate passes the reject-first gates and qualifies as a strong, bounded experimental conjecture. Its structural translation, rival comparison, falsifiers, and safety controls are unusually complete; empirical advantage, operating characteristics, and novelty remain open research questions."}