{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp04_retrieval_first_paired20_20260802","cell_id":"layer_decay_and_expiration_management__film_media_production","hypothesis_id":"H1","search_queries":["video review platform new version comments superseded feedback status resolved notes version official","online proofing comments new version archive previous feedback carry forward official video","film post production review notes version status resolved linked cut workflow","patent media review comments version superseded editing feedback","site:support.filestage.io version comments resolved new version proof comments official","site:help.wipster.io comments versions resolved feedback new version","site:help.autodesk.com ShotGrid notes version status linked official","site:help.syncsketch.com version comments copy forward review notes official"],"sources":[{"source_id":"S1","title":"Comments Panel Overview","publisher":"Frame.io / Adobe","url":"https://help.frame.io/en/articles/9105278-comments-panel-overview","source_class":"OFFICIAL_PRODUCT_DOCUMENTATION","claims_supported":["Frame.io supplies a manual Mark As Complete lifecycle state for feedback applied to a subsequent edit.","Comments can be filtered by completion state, copied to other media, linked, searched, and exported, preserving review history."]},{"source_id":"S2","title":"Manage Version Stacks","publisher":"Frame.io / Adobe","url":"https://next.developer.frame.io/platform/v2/manage-version-stacks","source_class":"OFFICIAL_PRODUCT_DOCUMENTATION","claims_supported":["Frame.io organizes successive media assets into ordered version stacks supporting navigation and side-by-side review.","The highest-numbered version is the displayed cover asset, while constituent versions remain preserved and independently removable or reorderable."]},{"source_id":"S3","title":"Tracking statuses for client-side productions","publisher":"Autodesk","url":"https://help.autodesk.com/cloudhelp/ENU/SG-Tutorials/files/SG_Tutorials_tu_tracking_statuses_html.html","source_class":"OFFICIAL_PRODUCT_DOCUMENTATION","claims_supported":["Flow Production Tracking defines Open, In Progress, and Closed states for production notes, where Closed includes notes that are completed or no longer relevant.","Only Open notes appear in some interfaces, and the platform documents automatic status triggers for related production entities.","Autodesk warns that tracking many production states can create confusion for people seeking relevant information."]},{"source_id":"S4","title":"Flow Production Tracking schema","publisher":"Autodesk","url":"https://help.autodesk.com/cloudhelp/ENU/SG-Administrator/files/ar-get-started/SG_Administrator_ar_get_started_ar_schema_html.html","source_class":"OFFICIAL_PRODUCT_DOCUMENTATION","claims_supported":["Production feedback notes can be linked to a specific Version, Task, and parent Shot or Asset.","Versions represent reviewable iterations, while notes have configurable statuses such as Ready to Start, In Progress, and Resolved."]},{"source_id":"S5","title":"View and compare proof versions","publisher":"Adobe Workfront","url":"https://experienceleague.adobe.com/en/docs/workfront-learn/tutorials-workfront/workfront-proof/upload-proofs/view-and-compare-proof-versions","source_class":"OFFICIAL_PRODUCT_DOCUMENTATION","claims_supported":["Workfront Proof supports version-specific comments and markup.","Users can identify the current proof version and compare it with an earlier version."]},{"source_id":"S6","title":"Timestamped Video Review for Editors, Teams & Clients","publisher":"VideoReview","url":"https://videoreview.pro/","source_class":"COMMERCIAL_FIRST_PARTY","claims_supported":["VideoReview scopes comments to the cut on which they were made while directing shared links to the latest cut.","It provides Open and Done comment states, side-by-side version comparison, review statuses, and exports preserving note status.","Its first-party description identifies scattered feedback and uncertainty about which version was reviewed as workflow problems."]},{"source_id":"S7","title":"Timestamped Video Feedback for Video Editors","publisher":"Clipback","url":"https://clipback.video/","source_class":"COMMERCIAL_FIRST_PARTY","claims_supported":["Clipback tracks revisions, retains comments, provides explicit approvals, and offers side-by-side version comparison.","Its first-party page says revisions resolve automatically as approval is granted, establishing an automated lifecycle transition triggered by approval rather than merely elapsed time."]}],"proximity":"SUBSTANTIAL_COLLISION","closest_analogues":[{"name":"VideoReview version-scoped comments and resolution states","similarity":"It already binds each note to a particular cut, exposes Open/Done states, keeps prior versions, points reviewers to the latest cut, and preserves status in exports; this implements most of the proposed protection against treating old-cut feedback as current.","remaining_difference":"The opened page does not establish an automatic per-note expired/superseded transition on every new cut, explicit renewal of still-valid notes, or a successor-lineage marker.","source_ids":["S6"]},{"name":"Autodesk Flow Production Tracking note/version/status model","similarity":"It links notes to reviewable Versions and production entities, supplies lifecycle states including no-longer-relevant closure, suppresses non-open notes in some views, and demonstrates status-trigger automation elsewhere in a professional media-production system.","remaining_difference":"The official documentation does not show creation or promotion of a successor Version automatically closing or superseding every prior Version's notes or requiring their renewal.","source_ids":["S3","S4"]},{"name":"Frame.io version stacks plus Mark As Complete","similarity":"It combines ordered cut versions, a latest-version cover, preserved earlier assets, version comparison, manual feedback completion, state filtering, copying, and exportable history.","remaining_difference":"Completion is described as a manual action after feedback is applied, not a revision-triggered expiry operation with explicit renewal and note-to-successor lineage.","source_ids":["S1","S2"]},{"name":"Clipback revision tracking with approval-triggered resolution","similarity":"It centralizes revision-specific comments, tracks every revision, compares versions, preserves history, and claims automatic resolution associated with approval.","remaining_difference":"Its documented trigger is approval, not the arrival of each revised cut, and the page does not establish per-note renewal, supersession labels, or lineage links.","source_ids":["S7"]}],"overlapping_components":["versioned cut and note identity","notes linked to the media version they reference","ordered revision history and latest-version designation","explicit note lifecycle states","state-based filtering or demotion of inactive notes","manual feedback resolution","side-by-side comparison with earlier cuts","preservation and export of review history","automatic status-transition precedent","current-cut review links"],"remaining_contrastive_claim":"In a film editorial review workflow, promoting a new cut automatically marks each prior-cut note expired or superseded, carries forward only explicitly renewed notes, and retains visible note lineage, thereby reducing stale-feedback edits beyond version scoping and manual resolution.","claim_falsifier":"The contrastive claim would be falsified by opened first-party documentation, a patent, or reproducible professional workflow showing that an existing system already performs revision-triggered per-note expiry, explicit renewal or carry-forward, and preserved successor lineage, or by controlled productions showing no reduction in superseded-feedback edits relative to version-scoped manual resolution.","problem_support":"MODERATE","recommendation":"RESEARCH","world_novelty_boundary":"This is a bounded ordinary-web-search assessment and expressly does not establish or imply world novelty; inaccessible products, private studio automations, unindexed patents, and undocumented configurations may already implement the remaining revision-triggered behavior."}