{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp06_four_proposal_generalization60_20260803","cell_id":"catalytic_pathway_enablement__environmental_climate","portfolio_valid":true,"proposal_assessments":[{"proposal_index":1,"complete":true,"causally_faithful":true,"materially_distinct":true,"reason":"Operationally specifies the eligible soil-to-signature transformation, repeated setup barrier, reusable chamber-and-controller facilitator, selective intake, turnover, regeneration, capacity metering, counterfactual, safeguards, authority, rollback, and falsifiers. Its causal path is repeated assay-setup reduction, distinct from coordination, gas oxidation, and nutrient separation."},{"proposal_index":2,"complete":true,"causally_faithful":true,"materially_distinct":true,"reason":"Defines a feasible anomaly-to-investigation-plan transformation and a standing broker that repeatedly lowers trust, access, translation, and scheduling barriers, then restores relationships, records, and human capacity. Consent, neutrality, eligibility, saturation, downstream capacity, measurement, deactivation, and fallback procedures are explicit."},{"proposal_index":3,"complete":true,"causally_faithful":true,"materially_distinct":true,"reason":"Implements literal multi-cycle biocatalysis: an immobilized methanotrophic biofilm selectively accelerates methane oxidation in a bounded residual-gas stream, with active-capacity control, mass-balance verification, inhibitor screening, biological regeneration or retirement, containment, fallback routing, and repeated-cycle falsification."},{"proposal_index":4,"complete":true,"causally_faithful":true,"materially_distinct":true,"reason":"Defines a recurring dilute-phosphorus-to-concentrated-fraction transformation using reusable selective sites that form and release a reversible intermediate through capture, elution, reconditioning, and restored-capacity testing. It distinguishes reusable turnover from disposable sorption or consumed precipitation and includes complete custody, hydraulic, selectivity, cofactor, bypass, and retirement controls."}],"pairwise_assessments":[{"proposal_a":1,"proposal_b":2,"same_problem":false,"same_intervention":false,"independent_opportunity":true,"key_difference":"Proposal 1 removes repeated laboratory configuration burden with an automated physical assay lane; proposal 2 removes interorganizational trust and coordination burden with a governed human-institutional broker."},{"proposal_a":1,"proposal_b":3,"same_problem":false,"same_intervention":false,"independent_opportunity":true,"key_difference":"Proposal 1 accelerates production of analytical evidence from soil samples through reusable assay setup; proposal 3 accelerates a biochemical methane-oxidation reaction in a residual gas stream through retained living catalytic capacity."},{"proposal_a":1,"proposal_b":4,"same_problem":false,"same_intervention":false,"independent_opportunity":true,"key_difference":"Proposal 1 standardizes and automates a measurement workflow; proposal 4 repeatedly separates dilute phosphorus through reversible binding, elution, and media reconditioning at a drainage interface."},{"proposal_a":2,"proposal_b":3,"same_problem":false,"same_intervention":false,"independent_opportunity":true,"key_difference":"Proposal 2 produces consented investigation plans by reusing relationships and coordination infrastructure; proposal 3 produces treated gas by reusing immobilized methanotrophic activity."},{"proposal_a":2,"proposal_b":4,"same_problem":false,"same_intervention":false,"independent_opportunity":true,"key_difference":"Proposal 2 addresses transient-anomaly response latency through institutional brokerage; proposal 4 addresses dilute nutrient recovery through a regenerable material-transfer bed."},{"proposal_a":3,"proposal_b":4,"same_problem":false,"same_intervention":false,"independent_opportunity":true,"key_difference":"Although both use fixed, monitored, regenerable flow-through beds, proposal 3 uses biological catalytic turnover to oxidize methane, whereas proposal 4 uses reversible selective binding and elution to transfer phosphorus between streams; their affected problems, active mechanisms, outputs, regeneration processes, and causal paths differ materially."}],"replacement_indices":[],"rationale":"All four proposals are operationally complete and preserve the archetype's defining closed cycle: a specified feasible transformation, recurring barrier, reusable selective facilitator, governed interface, measurable turnover and counterfactual, capacity and interference monitoring, regeneration or retirement, and neutrality and safety boundaries. Every pair differs in affected problem, intervention, and causal path; shared monitoring and regeneration components reflect archetype fidelity rather than duplicated opportunities."}