{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp07_retrospective_selector60_20260803","cell_code":"E7C017","selector_replication":3,"assessments":[{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_A","problem_reality_importance":87,"causal_archetype_fit":95,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":43,"operational_specificity":97,"falsifiability_test_quality":97,"adopter_partner_path":88,"deployability_complexity":74,"authority_safety_reversibility":97,"strict_potential":84,"empirical_partner_potential":94,"scrutiny_priority":91,"biggest_visible_risk":"The regenerable selective-bed concept looks highly vulnerable to existing sorption and nutrient-recovery practice, leaving only a narrow multi-cycle performance contrast after scrutiny.","rationale":"A real residual nutrient problem is tied directly to reversible binding, regeneration, and turnover rather than generic filtration. The contained bench and bypass studies have strong controls, complete mass balance, explicit kill criteria, identified operational owners, and decision-changing outcomes. Fouling, regenerant consumption, contaminated eluate, and hydraulic limits are serious but directly testable."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_B","problem_reality_importance":93,"causal_archetype_fit":94,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":36,"operational_specificity":95,"falsifiability_test_quality":95,"adopter_partner_path":86,"deployability_complexity":61,"authority_safety_reversibility":93,"strict_potential":77,"empirical_partner_potential":92,"scrutiny_priority":87,"biggest_visible_risk":"Methanotrophic biofilters are a known-looking treatment family, and real residual-gas conditions may make the claimed regenerable cartridge neither distinctive nor operationally superior.","rationale":"Residual methane is consequential, and retained biological activity is causally essential to the proposed low-concentration oxidation pathway. A facility can resolve the key uncertainty with a sealed slipstream, inactive-support control, carbon balance, repeated recovery cycles, and automatic fallback. Flammability, pressure, feed inhibition, byproducts, and substantial cofactor demands reduce strict deployability."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_C","problem_reality_importance":66,"causal_archetype_fit":79,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":29,"operational_specificity":94,"falsifiability_test_quality":97,"adopter_partner_path":92,"deployability_complexity":90,"authority_safety_reversibility":98,"strict_potential":65,"empirical_partner_potential":87,"scrutiny_priority":74,"biggest_visible_risk":"The intervention may reduce to conventional laboratory workflow standardization and automation, with incubation or interpretation—not setup—remaining the binding delay.","rationale":"The matched-aliquot design is unusually clean, bounded, reversible, and capable of changing an adoption decision. Laboratory ownership and rollback are clear. However, the consequence is less substantial than the environmental treatment proposals, the facilitator framing is less causally essential, and the remaining contrastive claim appears especially exposed to ordinary automation, harmonized protocols, and capacity-management practice."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_D","problem_reality_importance":79,"causal_archetype_fit":89,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":49,"operational_specificity":92,"falsifiability_test_quality":88,"adopter_partner_path":76,"deployability_complexity":69,"authority_safety_reversibility":96,"strict_potential":70,"empirical_partner_potential":89,"scrutiny_priority":81,"biggest_visible_risk":"The broker depends on durable voluntary participation across many independent parties, so the decisive coordination pathway may not exist at sufficient scale or frequency for a credible matched evaluation.","rationale":"The recurring trust, access, custody, and scheduling barrier is structurally credible, and the standing broker is more causally specific than a contact list or alert system. Synthetic exercises and voluntary pilots safely test permissions and workflow integrity. Its empirical-partner lane is strong, but multi-organization adoption, rare heterogeneous events, case-selection bias, and difficulty matching transient anomalies weaken strict inference and deployability."}],"rank_order":["CANDIDATE_A","CANDIDATE_B","CANDIDATE_D","CANDIDATE_C"],"top_choice":"CANDIDATE_A","portfolio_observation":"A and B offer the strongest consequential, bounded physical tests but are visibly vulnerable to mature-looking treatment families. D is the best coordination-service partner study, while C has the cleanest experiment and easiest deployment but the weakest importance and distinctiveness profile.","confidence":"HIGH"}