{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp07_retrospective_selector60_20260803","cell_code":"E7C030","selector_replication":2,"assessments":[{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_A","problem_reality_importance":86,"causal_archetype_fit":88,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":62,"operational_specificity":92,"falsifiability_test_quality":94,"adopter_partner_path":84,"deployability_complexity":58,"authority_safety_reversibility":95,"strict_potential":78,"empirical_partner_potential":91,"scrutiny_priority":84,"biggest_visible_risk":"Global, temporal, or nondeterministic dependencies may make safe residual rendering so audit- and fallback-heavy that it provides no advantage over complete rendering.","rationale":"The proposal addresses consequential render waste with an archetype-essential prediction/residual/audit loop, explicit provenance, sharp fallback rules, and an unusually decision-relevant retrospective test. Its contrastive position is vulnerable because dependency invalidation, caching, differential rendering, and image prediction all look close to existing practice; the governed reconstruction loop must carry the distinction. Deployment is technically complex, but an authorized archived-shot study can resolve the central economic and fidelity uncertainty without production risk."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_B","problem_reality_importance":78,"causal_archetype_fit":82,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":38,"operational_specificity":91,"falsifiability_test_quality":92,"adopter_partner_path":81,"deployability_complexity":68,"authority_safety_reversibility":94,"strict_potential":59,"empirical_partner_potential":82,"scrutiny_priority":68,"biggest_visible_risk":"The intervention may reduce to a conventional predictive video codec with keyframes, error control, and adaptive quality expressed as production governance.","rationale":"The constrained-link problem is credible, actors and authority are clear, and the offline comparison can directly test bandwidth, latency, fidelity, and editorial decisions. Yet prediction-plus-residual transmission, resynchronizing keyframes, packet checks, and fallback are strongly standard-looking codec features. Consequence-weighted allocation and independent audits provide a possible contrast, but may add operational cost or bias without establishing a durable distinct claim."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_C","problem_reality_importance":84,"causal_archetype_fit":96,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":78,"operational_specificity":91,"falsifiability_test_quality":96,"adopter_partner_path":86,"deployability_complexity":61,"authority_safety_reversibility":94,"strict_potential":86,"empirical_partner_potential":94,"scrutiny_priority":92,"biggest_visible_risk":"Prediction error or timing drift could attenuate external speech, alarms, or other protected sounds precisely when they overlap the modeled equipment signature.","rationale":"Copied equipment commands are causally essential rather than decorative: they distinguish predicted self-generated sound from unexplained acoustic residuals. The scope is bounded to enrolled equipment, authoritative recordings remain untouched, raw monitoring is instantly available, and protected signals force bypass. The proposed offline study contains decisive adversarial overlap and synchronization conditions, qualified listeners, direct-monitor comparison, and hard failure criteria. Live deployment remains demanding and safety-sensitive, but the partner study can falsify the mechanism before exposure."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_D","problem_reality_importance":76,"causal_archetype_fit":77,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":58,"operational_specificity":86,"falsifiability_test_quality":91,"adopter_partner_path":83,"deployability_complexity":55,"authority_safety_reversibility":92,"strict_potential":66,"empirical_partner_potential":86,"scrutiny_priority":74,"biggest_visible_risk":"The manifest and residual workflow may consume more expert attention than full dailies while suppressing deviations outside its predefined continuity variables.","rationale":"The proposal makes silence, versions, provenance, audits, and fallback operationally explicit, and its retrospective counterbalanced test can measure misses and total review effort. However, much of the observation and comparison process depends on labor-intensive human structuring, while exception reports and continuity logs are close rivals. The archetype helps organize attention but is less causally indispensable than in the command-correlated audio or computational residual proposals. Protected bypasses and read-only testing make it a credible empirical-partner candidate."}],"rank_order":["CANDIDATE_C","CANDIDATE_A","CANDIDATE_D","CANDIDATE_B"],"top_choice":"CANDIDATE_C","portfolio_observation":"All four proposals offer bounded retrospective studies with strong reversibility and explicit raw-state fallback. The main separator is whether prediction-relative residuals are causally indispensable and support a durable contrast: C is strongest on causal necessity, A on measurable computational value, D is credible but labor-heavy, and B is most vulnerable to collapsing into standard codec practice.","confidence":"HIGH"}