{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp07_retrospective_selector60_20260803","cell_code":"E7C048","selector_replication":2,"assessments":[{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_A","problem_reality_importance":91,"causal_archetype_fit":95,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":80,"operational_specificity":96,"falsifiability_test_quality":93,"adopter_partner_path":87,"deployability_complexity":70,"authority_safety_reversibility":97,"strict_potential":89,"empirical_partner_potential":93,"scrutiny_priority":92,"biggest_visible_risk":"The abstract permission states may erase culturally significant distinctions or ambiguities, making a technically conforming adapter misrepresent community authority.","rationale":"The proposal targets consequential authorization failures and makes representation independence causally central rather than decorative. Its interface, invariants, authority allocation, synthetic dual-adapter test, falsifiers, and rollback are unusually specific. Scrutiny should focus on whether permission contracts of this kind are already standard and whether one public state model can preserve heterogeneous governance meanings without legitimizing an unauthorized mapping."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_B","problem_reality_importance":89,"causal_archetype_fit":96,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":66,"operational_specificity":97,"falsifiability_test_quality":97,"adopter_partner_path":92,"deployability_complexity":78,"authority_safety_reversibility":95,"strict_potential":84,"empirical_partner_potential":96,"scrutiny_priority":90,"biggest_visible_risk":"Defining unique sampling units and deduplicating records embeds substantive identity judgments that conformance testing cannot validate.","rationale":"This is the most mechanically testable proposal: permutation, reserialization, duplicate consolidation, fixed seeds, probabilities, and injected faulty adapters create decision-relevant evidence. A study team can run the bounded synthetic exercise without participant exposure. Its strict opportunity is moderated by strong prior-art vulnerability because immutable frames, seeded reproducibility, deduplication, versioned designs, and backend conformance resemble established sampling and data-engineering practice."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_C","problem_reality_importance":78,"causal_archetype_fit":92,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":74,"operational_specificity":93,"falsifiability_test_quality":91,"adopter_partner_path":84,"deployability_complexity":73,"authority_safety_reversibility":95,"strict_potential":81,"empirical_partner_potential":87,"scrutiny_priority":84,"biggest_visible_risk":"A study-approved abstract vocabulary may flatten locally specific or contested kin relations while giving derived paths unwarranted semantic authority.","rationale":"The distinction between attributed claims and objective kinship facts, preservation of contradiction and missingness, and traced rule-versioned derivations give the archetype real causal work. The two-backend synthetic study is bounded and capable of falsifying representation independence. The problem is consequential within research practice but narrower than the leading candidates, and deployment ultimately depends on resolving semantic questions that a technical oracle cannot settle."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_D","problem_reality_importance":86,"causal_archetype_fit":85,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":55,"operational_specificity":95,"falsifiability_test_quality":90,"adopter_partner_path":82,"deployability_complexity":69,"authority_safety_reversibility":96,"strict_potential":73,"empirical_partner_potential":86,"scrutiny_priority":79,"biggest_visible_risk":"Formal status transitions may convert relational and negotiated mutual aid into an apparent service obligation, enabling pressure or surveillance of autonomous groups.","rationale":"The proposal offers a concrete authority-scoped state machine, idempotency rules, privacy boundaries, and a safe multi-group tabletop. However, federated workflow APIs and adapter conformance look highly exposed to standard-practice prior art, while major real-world failures may arise from capacity, trust, request ambiguity, or safety rather than representation coupling. A partner study could still determine whether status translation is materially causal and whether legitimate local states can be mapped without coercive simplification."}],"rank_order":["CANDIDATE_A","CANDIDATE_B","CANDIDATE_C","CANDIDATE_D"],"top_choice":"CANDIDATE_A","portfolio_observation":"All four proposals are unusually complete instances of the same opaque behavioral-contract pattern. A and C offer the strongest domain-specific semantic contrasts, B offers the cleanest decisive partner experiment but faces greater standard-practice exposure, and D has practical value yet appears most vulnerable to being a conventional federated workflow integration whose dominant constraints lie outside the interface.","confidence":"MODERATE"}