{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp07_retrospective_selector60_20260803","cell_code":"E7C049","selector_replication":3,"assessments":[{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_A","problem_reality_importance":96,"causal_archetype_fit":84,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":76,"operational_specificity":94,"falsifiability_test_quality":92,"adopter_partner_path":79,"deployability_complexity":72,"authority_safety_reversibility":97,"strict_potential":81,"empirical_partner_potential":85,"scrutiny_priority":83,"biggest_visible_risk":"The ceremony could add public pressure and false assurance to a domain already governed by confidential, highly formal independence controls.","rationale":"The problem is consequential, the absent-user and commercial-pressure framing is structurally relevant, and the synthetic comparison has decision-changing measures and strong safeguards. Its vulnerability is that improved confirmations, consultation, and acceptance controls may deliver the same routing benefit with less exposure and burden."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_B","problem_reality_importance":95,"causal_archetype_fit":79,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":68,"operational_specificity":95,"falsifiability_test_quality":96,"adopter_partner_path":87,"deployability_complexity":85,"authority_safety_reversibility":96,"strict_potential":82,"empirical_partner_potential":95,"scrutiny_priority":89,"biggest_visible_risk":"The circulating token may be decorative relative to anonymous issue submission, an explicit tracker, and credible quality-review follow-through, while visibly exposing junior participants.","rationale":"It targets a serious rank-and-deadline failure mode and offers the strongest bounded partner experiment: identical seeded contradictions, time-matched conditions, operational routing outcomes, and explicit stopping criteria. Prior-art vulnerability is comparatively high because several nearest rivals already address voice, contradiction tracking, and escalation directly."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_C","problem_reality_importance":89,"causal_archetype_fit":92,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":86,"operational_specificity":93,"falsifiability_test_quality":85,"adopter_partner_path":88,"deployability_complexity":79,"authority_safety_reversibility":96,"strict_potential":87,"empirical_partner_potential":91,"scrutiny_priority":91,"biggest_visible_risk":"A selective control-origin narrative could harden into an authoritative myth that obscures disputed facts, changed assumptions, or obsolete control design.","rationale":"Reenactment, reciprocal exchange, stewardship transfer, and governed renewal are causally connected to the stated loss of provenance across turnover rather than merely decorating a control review. The synthetic first step is safe and partner-ready, though the proposed evidence design needs a content-equivalent comparator to isolate ritual effects from simple exposure and training."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_D","problem_reality_importance":88,"causal_archetype_fit":89,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":78,"operational_specificity":94,"falsifiability_test_quality":88,"adopter_partner_path":89,"deployability_complexity":82,"authority_safety_reversibility":96,"strict_potential":79,"empirical_partner_potential":91,"scrutiny_priority":85,"biggest_visible_risk":"A compelling release ceremony could normalize recurring overwork by substituting symbolic recognition and promises for enforceable recovery, compensation, staffing, or schedule changes.","rationale":"The marked transition is well matched to ambiguous close-mode boundaries, and the proposal carefully preserves official task and employment authority. A willing controller-workforce partner could test comprehension and routing quickly, but the decisive claim about actual recovery and leadership follow-through requires a longer authorized study beyond the dry run."}],"rank_order":["CANDIDATE_C","CANDIDATE_B","CANDIDATE_D","CANDIDATE_A"],"top_choice":"CANDIDATE_C","portfolio_observation":"C has the strongest combination of archetype-essential mechanism and resilience to simpler-process substitution. B offers the cleanest immediate experiment but looks most vulnerable to established issue-management practices; D has strong partner potential but depends on material workforce follow-through; A addresses the highest-stakes objective but faces the greatest regulatory sensitivity and deployment burden.","confidence":"HIGH"}