{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp07_retrospective_selector60_20260803","cell_code":"E7C054","selector_replication":1,"assessments":[{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_A","problem_reality_importance":70,"causal_archetype_fit":71,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":59,"operational_specificity":86,"falsifiability_test_quality":76,"adopter_partner_path":74,"deployability_complexity":69,"authority_safety_reversibility":84,"strict_potential":62,"empirical_partner_potential":72,"scrutiny_priority":66,"biggest_visible_risk":"The observance may canonize a senior creator’s interpretation while appearing to preserve plural readings.","rationale":"The turnover and founder-dependence problem is credible, and reenactment plus cross-craft interpretation is more causally relevant here than in a routine administrative process. The pilot is bounded, reversible, and carefully consent-guarded. However, the outcome is difficult to distinguish from benefits achievable through stronger bibles, tone meetings, continuity stewardship, and consultant review; meaning coherence is also subjective, making the proposed evidence less decisive than the operational detail suggests."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_B","problem_reality_importance":96,"causal_archetype_fit":88,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":50,"operational_specificity":94,"falsifiability_test_quality":91,"adopter_partner_path":94,"deployability_complexity":89,"authority_safety_reversibility":91,"strict_potential":78,"empirical_partner_potential":95,"scrutiny_priority":91,"biggest_visible_risk":"A rehearsed stop-work enactment could become safety theater or expose junior callers to informal retaliation without improving real hazard response.","rationale":"This addresses a consequential, observable rank-and-coordination failure, and the embodied call-and-response rehearsal is causally connected to making an abstract right usable. The seven-minute idle-equipment pilot has clear authority, halt conditions, compatible operational measures, and a partner can decisively test knowledge, refusal, response compatibility, issue disposition, and perceived retaliation. Its main strict-lane weakness is substantial resemblance to drills, toolbox talks, and safety-culture exercises, but that prior-art vulnerability is outweighed at scrutiny stage by exceptional empirical-partner value."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_C","problem_reality_importance":81,"causal_archetype_fit":58,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":49,"operational_specificity":87,"falsifiability_test_quality":84,"adopter_partner_path":83,"deployability_complexity":76,"authority_safety_reversibility":86,"strict_potential":55,"empirical_partner_potential":80,"scrutiny_priority":64,"biggest_visible_risk":"Ceremonial recognition may create implied credit promises or substitute gratitude for compensation and formal correction.","rationale":"Fragmented credit provenance and departed-worker access are real, measurable problems, and the bounded roster audit and handoff study could produce useful partner evidence. Yet the strongest causal components are the restricted ledger, reconciliation, private claims channel, ownership, and deadlines—not the displayed roll or witnessing ceremony. Databases, departmental verification, and formal correction processes therefore threaten the contrastive claim, while public recognition introduces privacy, hierarchy, and entitlement-confusion risks."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_D","problem_reality_importance":91,"causal_archetype_fit":79,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":65,"operational_specificity":91,"falsifiability_test_quality":89,"adopter_partner_path":90,"deployability_complexity":85,"authority_safety_reversibility":93,"strict_potential":81,"empirical_partner_potential":91,"scrutiny_priority":88,"biggest_visible_risk":"The covenant may give an ethically reassuring appearance to a cut while documented contributor obligations remain materially unmet.","rationale":"Contributor commitments becoming detached from footage across editorial turnover is consequential and structurally credible. Recurring renewal at cut milestones plausibly matters because obligations can change with context and use, although databases, checklists, and an empowered liaison remain strong rivals. The two-milestone pilot is unusually bounded and decision-relevant: it can test retrieval, shared understanding, ownership gaps, action disposition, coercion, and confidentiality while preserving competent editorial, consent, and legal authority."}],"rank_order":["CANDIDATE_B","CANDIDATE_D","CANDIDATE_A","CANDIDATE_C"],"top_choice":"CANDIDATE_B","portfolio_observation":"B and D form the strongest scrutiny pair: B offers the clearest high-consequence partner test despite prior-art exposure, while D has the best balance of a meaningful residual claim and a bounded longitudinal study. A has a plausible archetype fit but softer outcomes; C’s useful mechanism is predominantly administrative rather than ceremonial.","confidence":"HIGH"}