{"schema_version":1,"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp07_retrospective_selector60_20260803","cell_code":"E7C054","selector_replication":2,"assessments":[{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_A","problem_reality_importance":86,"causal_archetype_fit":82,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":73,"operational_specificity":91,"falsifiability_test_quality":88,"adopter_partner_path":84,"deployability_complexity":82,"authority_safety_reversibility":92,"strict_potential":80,"empirical_partner_potential":88,"scrutiny_priority":84,"biggest_visible_risk":"The observance may become ethics theater, creating reassurance while documented obligations remain unresolved or are better handled by an empowered ledger-and-liaison workflow.","rationale":"The proposal addresses a consequential and observable documentary-governance failure with a bounded two-milestone pilot, explicit authority boundaries, strong halt conditions, and decision-linked measures. Recurring collective renewal plausibly contributes beyond mere record storage, especially across turnover, although its residual advantage over a strong obligation database, empowered liaison, and mandatory review remains the key prior-art vulnerability."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_B","problem_reality_importance":96,"causal_archetype_fit":91,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":70,"operational_specificity":94,"falsifiability_test_quality":92,"adopter_partner_path":91,"deployability_complexity":86,"authority_safety_reversibility":90,"strict_potential":87,"empirical_partner_potential":94,"scrutiny_priority":91,"biggest_visible_risk":"A rehearsal could confuse real stop, emergency, and restart signals or legitimize management safety theater without improving treatment of actual stop-work calls.","rationale":"This is the most consequential problem and the archetype is causally central: a low-status worker visibly invokes a real right and departments demonstrate recognized uptake. The equipment-idle, single-location pilot is tightly bounded, partner-ready, reversible, and tested against knowledge, compatible responses, coercion, ownership, and later conduct. Its main scrutiny issue is whether familiar safety drills or toolbox practices already capture the meaningful contrast."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_C","problem_reality_importance":68,"causal_archetype_fit":67,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":59,"operational_specificity":86,"falsifiability_test_quality":80,"adopter_partner_path":74,"deployability_complexity":78,"authority_safety_reversibility":87,"strict_potential":61,"empirical_partner_potential":76,"scrutiny_priority":68,"biggest_visible_risk":"The ritual may canonize the creative lead’s interpretation, narrowing productive ambiguity while duplicating story conferences, table reads, bibles, and continuity practice.","rationale":"The turnover and founder-dependence problem is credible, and the pilot has careful consent, provenance, ownership, and retirement provisions. However, consequences are less acute, outcome judgments are more interpretive, and the reenactment layer appears less causally necessary than strengthened documentation and ordinary cross-department creative review. A partner could still test consistency, stewardship transfer, action traceability, and conformity pressure."},{"blind_id":"CANDIDATE_D","problem_reality_importance":84,"causal_archetype_fit":74,"distinctiveness_prior_art_resilience":65,"operational_specificity":90,"falsifiability_test_quality":89,"adopter_partner_path":86,"deployability_complexity":81,"authority_safety_reversibility":91,"strict_potential":72,"empirical_partner_potential":85,"scrutiny_priority":78,"biggest_visible_risk":"Workers may mistake provisional public recognition for binding credit or material remedy, while hierarchy and inaccurate witness claims distort the record.","rationale":"Credit-memory failures across temporary workforces are concrete and the ten-entry phase-boundary study could decisively test provenance, consent, handoff, correction, and disposition. Authority and rollback are unusually clear. The weakness is causal necessity: most practical benefit may come from reconciliation, a private claims channel, and a durable credits ledger, leaving the witnessed roll vulnerable as an emotionally potent but nonessential wrapper."}],"rank_order":["CANDIDATE_B","CANDIDATE_A","CANDIDATE_D","CANDIDATE_C"],"top_choice":"CANDIDATE_B","portfolio_observation":"All four proposals are unusually bounded and safety-conscious, but their principal shared vulnerability is that the administrative ledger, empowered steward, and closure workflow may do more causal work than the ritual enactment. B best survives that concern because embodied cross-rank invocation and coordinated uptake directly test the uncertainty at issue; A is the strongest alternative, while D and especially C face greater substitution by ordinary workflow improvements.","confidence":"HIGH"}