{"judgments":[{"pair_id":"E12Q046","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":2},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":3,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":2,"contrivance_risk":4},"winner":"A","reason":"A directly establishes an auditable additive coverage measure over overlapping audit procedures with a practical shadow reconstruction. B is measurable but its specialized manifold is burdensome and weakly practical for the accounting use."},{"pair_id":"E12Q002","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":2},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":3,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":3},"winner":"A","reason":"A fully implements lineage, context-shift, ownership, and release governance for a history-bearing material substrate. B offers useful contaminant containment, but the guard train only partially realizes a lineage audit."},{"pair_id":"E12Q017","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":1},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":2,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":4,"practicality":2,"contrivance_risk":5},"winner":"A","reason":"A directly measures and governs decay of a defined human review cue. B is a physical retention-control analogy, not an attention/priming intervention, and relies on difficult sentinel representativeness."},{"pair_id":"E12Q029","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":2},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":4,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":3,"contrivance_risk":4},"winner":"A","reason":"A directly preserves recurring accounting maps over one journal substrate, with explicit selection, isolation, and re-entry evidence. B realizes map selection mechanically but adds a complex device to a problem more simply governed through controlled digital mappings."},{"pair_id":"E12Q044","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":1},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":2,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":5},"winner":"A","reason":"A is a well-bounded anchor-reset protocol with independent estimation, calibration, and downstream trace. B is a sound crystallization-history experiment, but translates cognitive anchoring into physical seeding too decoratively to fit the archetype."},{"pair_id":"E12Q036","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":2},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":4,"domain_fidelity":3,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":3,"contrivance_risk":5},"winner":"A","reason":"A cleanly separates grammar, premises, inference, derivation, and interpretation for consolidation decisions. B physically enforces a narrow transfer calculus, but is an overbuilt and limited substitute for an accounting formal system."}]}