{"judgments":[{"pair_id":"E12Q027","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":1},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":4,"domain_fidelity":3,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":2,"contrivance_risk":4},"winner":"A","reason":"A directly preserves reverse dependency reasoning and appropriately respects accounting-control and auditor-independence boundaries. B is carefully testable but makes a highly specialized physical device carry an accounting-control problem with uncertain deployment plausibility."},{"pair_id":"E12Q028","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":1},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":2,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":4},"winner":"A","reason":"A instantiates legitimate, bounded, plural, autonomy-preserving mentor enculturation in a safety-critical chemical setting. B proposes a plausible crystallization experiment, but its molecule-to-mentor mapping is largely decorative and lacks the archetype's relational authority and agency structure."},{"pair_id":"E12Q015","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":1},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":3,"domain_fidelity":3,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":3,"contrivance_risk":4},"winner":"A","reason":"A directly addresses scanner-score anchoring through blinded contextual estimates, evidence calibration, and downstream trace repair. B offers a bounded thermo-hydraulic control concept, but recasts a cognitive reference-point audit as passive physical regulation and relies on a limited thermal proxy."}]}