{"judgments":[{"pair_id":"E12Q045","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":4,"domain_fidelity":2,"causal_coherence":3,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":2,"contrivance_risk":5},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":1},"winner":"B","reason":"B directly governs a bounded replay search with evidence-cited exclusions, diversity, audit sampling, and reentry. A is carefully testable but depends on a fragile and highly fault-class-specific thermal mapping."},{"pair_id":"E12Q062","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":4,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":2},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":1},"winner":"B","reason":"B maps activation decay to directly measurable, temperature-dependent repair kinetics and tests the threshold against mechanical outcomes. A is responsible and bounded but cue freshness is less clearly the operative safety limitation than broader qualification and procedure design."},{"pair_id":"E12Q051","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":1},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":4,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":2},"winner":"A","reason":"A squarely targets the shared dependency-ready release, finite broker, duplicate work, capacity-aware admission, and fairness. B provides credible physical staging but covers less of the archetype’s feedback and coalescing structure."},{"pair_id":"E12Q012","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":2,"causal_coherence":3,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":2,"contrivance_risk":5},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":1},"winner":"B","reason":"B preserves pre-outcome predictions, signed residuals, reliability filtering, credit assignment, and held-out checks in a natural CI learning setting. A is elaborately specified, but its mechanical forecast-error apparatus is an uncertain and impractical substitute for established thermal control."},{"pair_id":"E12Q030","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":1},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":4,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":2},"winner":"A","reason":"A directly addresses recurring incompatible semantic maps on a shared telemetry substrate, with authenticated keys, visible selection, isolation, abstention, and reproducible reentry. B is a strong physical analogue but has a narrower, mostly static mapping lifecycle."},{"pair_id":"E12Q047","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":3,"contrivance_risk":3},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":2},"winner":"B","reason":"B gives a bounded material mechanism for absorbing a cure peak and returning heat during the useful tail, with controls that isolate latent-heat effects from dilution and conductivity. A is structurally strong but introduces a more difficult tool-level coupling and runaway-control problem."}]}