{"judgments":[{"pair_id":"E12Q059","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":5,"contrivance_risk":1},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":4,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":3,"contrivance_risk":4},"winner":"A","reason":"A directly implements prospective signed residual learning with credible metrology, attribution, and noise controls. B retains the core loop but relies on a less representative mechanical proxy and a notably forced self-adjusting mechanism."},{"pair_id":"E12Q003","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":3,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":3,"contrivance_risk":5},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":2},"winner":"B","reason":"B cleanly instantiates vocabulary, grammar, axioms, transitions, traces, closure, and versioned guardrails. A is a useful physical screening device but makes formal derivation largely metaphorical and is highly contrived."},{"pair_id":"E12Q066","scores_a":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":5,"causal_coherence":5,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":4,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":1},"scores_b":{"structural_fidelity":5,"domain_fidelity":4,"causal_coherence":4,"operational_specificity":5,"testability":5,"practicality":4,"contrivance_risk":3},"winner":"A","reason":"A maps responsibility, interfaces, stewardship, encapsulation, and reintegration directly onto a genuine accounting entanglement. B is a coherent physical modularization, but its added weighing and transfer architecture introduces material-handling and measurement complications not clearly justified by the accounting problem."}]}