{"actors":["Athlete","Lead coach","Sport scientist","Strength and conditioning coach"],"affected_objective":"Preserve decision-relevant training observations for longitudinal workload interpretation and program review without slowing live coaching.","arm":"COMMON_P1","authority_safety":{"authorized_first_step":"Run a shadow-mode simulation on de-identified records from six previously completed training sessions; do not use its output to alter training.","decision_authority":"The lead coach retains authority over training decisions; the slow athlete ledger is authoritative for retrospective analysis, while scratchpad entries are explicitly provisional.","excluded_actions":["Changing training load, exercise selection, return-to-play status, or competition participation from fast-store data alone","Recording diagnoses, intimate health information, or unrelated personal data in the fast store","Automatically promoting entries without review","Overwriting original observations or resolving conflicts without an audit trail"],"halt_rollback":"Halt the test if provisional entries appear in decision-facing summaries, athlete identifiers leak, or reconciliation cannot recover source versions; revoke access to the test view and delete the isolated shadow dataset."},"baseline":"Coaches record observations in paper notes, messaging threads, or memory during sessions and later enter selected details manually into the athlete-management record, without a shared transfer deadline, promotion rule, provenance marker, or reconciliation check.","candidate_id":"fast_slow_store_coupling__sport_science__COMMON_P1","causal_chain":["A coach captures a timestamped observation in the session scratchpad without interrupting the training flow.","The scratchpad keeps recent observations locally available and marks every item as provisional, time-limited, and attributable.","A risk flag triggers immediate review; otherwise, the post-session consolidation window collects pending items before expiration.","The sport scientist validates context, normalizes exercise and workload terms, links relevant sensor data, deduplicates repeated notes, and preserves uncertainty and provenance.","Reviewed items meeting the promotion rule enter the longitudinal athlete ledger; rejected or redundant items receive an explicit disposition before scratchpad eviction.","Version comparison detects conflicts between the scratchpad, sensor feed, and ledger, routing unresolved discrepancies to human review.","Subsequent retrospective analysis reads the coherent ledger rather than treating transient scratchpad content as durable truth."],"cell_id":"fast_slow_store_coupling__sport_science","consequence":"Potentially useful context is lost, delayed, or detached from provenance, while unreviewed impressions can also become shadow records; later program reviews may therefore rely on incomplete or internally inconsistent histories.","diversity_from_prior_proposals":"Not assessed against other proposals because runtime isolation prohibits inspection; this candidate is specifically grounded in the transfer of live coaching observations into a governed longitudinal athlete ledger.","experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp13_second_slot_policy60_20260806","intervention":"Create a bounded session scratchpad coupled to a longitudinal athlete ledger. The scratchpad accepts timestamped, low-friction observations during training, expires routine entries after 24 hours, and triggers immediate review only for predefined safety flags. Within two hours after each session, a sport scientist reviews pending entries, validates them against session context and available sensor data, normalizes terminology, deduplicates them, preserves source and uncertainty, and either promotes them to the ledger or records a rejection reason. The ledger remains authoritative for longitudinal analysis, and versioned reconciliation exposes conflicts rather than silently merging them.","mechanism_mapping":[{"counterfactual_removal":"Without a write-back path, rapid observations would remain disposable local notes and could not contribute reliably to the longitudinal record.","mechanism_slug":"write_back_cache_with_durable_backing_store","role":"The session scratchpad accepts rapid provisional writes and flushes reviewed observations into the durable athlete ledger."},{"counterfactual_removal":"Without consolidation, raw impressions, duplicated notes, and mismatched terminology could enter the ledger without stable context.","mechanism_slug":"short_term_to_long_term_memory_consolidation_routine","role":"Post-session review transforms fragile observations into normalized, provenance-bearing longitudinal records."},{"counterfactual_removal":"Without versioned reconciliation, discrepancies among coach notes, sensor records, and existing ledger entries could create silent split-brain histories.","mechanism_slug":"commit_log_and_compaction_cycle","role":"An append-only audit history preserves source versions while reviewed entries are compacted into the current longitudinal view."}],"nearest_rivals":["A single athlete-management form completed during training, which preserves one authoritative store but may impose validation overhead during live coaching","An ordinary cache of recent athlete records, which improves retrieval but does not consolidate new observations into durable memory","A post-session survey, which collects delayed summaries but does not protect timestamped traces captured during the session","A temporary intake queue, which stages notes but lacks governed transformation, promotion, expiration, and reconciliation"],"negative_tests":{"intervention_falsifier":"In the shadow test, the intervention is falsified if it does not reduce unmatched observation-to-ledger records or median capture time relative to replaying the same sessions through the baseline workflow, or if it introduces any unresolved provenance loss or provisional-data use.","problem_falsifier":"The proposed problem is unsupported if reconstructed completed sessions show that decision-relevant observations are already entered promptly into one authoritative record with traceable provenance and no material discrepancy between live notes and the longitudinal ledger.","risks":["The scratchpad becomes a shadow athlete record.","Routine review promotes subjective coaching impressions as if they were measurements.","Transfer workload creates a backlog that outlives the scratchpad expiration window.","Sensitive athlete information is duplicated into a less controlled layer.","Frequent alerts interrupt coaching or encourage defensive documentation.","Terminology normalization removes uncertainty or context from the original observation."] ,"strongest_counterevidence":"If timestamped audits show that existing live observations already reach the longitudinal record with preserved provenance before they are needed, the added second store would create complexity without addressing the stated failure."},"next_evidence_step":"Using de-identified data from six completed sessions, have two staff members replay the baseline and proposed shadow workflows. Measure observation capture time, the fraction of source observations traceably dispositioned, duplicate entries, unresolved conflicts, expired unreviewed items, and any provisional item exposed to a decision-facing view. Stop after six sessions and make no athlete-management or training changes.","observable_state":"For each active session, a small timestamped scratchpad shows provisional observations, source, athlete pseudonym, exercise context, expiry time, and review status; a separate longitudinal ledger shows only reviewed entries with provenance, normalized terms, version history, and conflict status. A dashboard exposes pending-transfer count, oldest pending age, expired items, reconciliation conflicts, and stale scratchpad reads.","prior_art_status":"UNSEARCHED","problem":"During training, coaches need to record brief technique, exertion, discomfort, and contextual observations quickly, but the longitudinal athlete record requires validation, consistent terminology, provenance, and reconciliation with sensor data. Using the durable record during every drill can interrupt live coaching, while relying on notebooks, messages, or memory allows fragile observations to expire or become unmarked shadow truth.","proposal_index":1,"remaining_contrastive_claim":"The candidate is not merely a recent-record cache or temporary note queue: its defining feature is governed transformation and reconciliation from a provisional session store into an authoritative longitudinal athlete ledger.","revision_record":{"claim_changes":[],"conceptual_changes":[],"evidence_changes":[],"operational_changes":[],"parent_version":null,"progress_targets_addressed":[]},"schema_version":1,"structural_mapping":[{"archetype_element":"Fast Volatile Store","domain_realization":"A session-scoped coaching scratchpad optimized for one-tap, timestamped observations and recent-session access."},{"archetype_element":"Slow Integrated Store","domain_realization":"A longitudinal athlete ledger containing reviewed observations, workload context, provenance, and version history."},{"archetype_element":"Read/Write Routing Rule","domain_realization":"Live, reversible observations write to the scratchpad; retrospective analysis reads the ledger; safety-sensitive or durable decisions require ledger confirmation and responsible human judgment."},{"archetype_element":"Transfer Trigger or Cadence","domain_realization":"Predefined safety flags trigger immediate review, while routine observations enter a consolidation window ending two hours after the session."},{"archetype_element":"Consolidation Transform","domain_realization":"Human review validates context, normalizes terminology, links sensor records, deduplicates entries, and retains source uncertainty."},{"archetype_element":"Promotion and Eviction Rule","domain_realization":"Only relevant, attributable, interpretable observations are promoted; routine scratchpad items expire after 24 hours once dispositioned, while unresolved items block eviction and raise a backlog alert."},{"archetype_element":"Freshness and Authority Marker","domain_realization":"Scratchpad entries display provisional and expiry labels; ledger entries display review status and remain authoritative for longitudinal use."},{"archetype_element":"Consistency Reconciliation Check","domain_realization":"Version comparison identifies conflicts among scratchpad observations, sensor timestamps, and ledger entries and routes them to named reviewers without overwriting sources."}],"title":"Session Scratchpad to Longitudinal Athlete Ledger","version":0}