{"judgments":[{"pair_id":"E13Q055","reason":"A is an exceptionally faithful predictive precommitment application but largely repeats P1's athlete-session forecasting structure. B is less certain because short loaded bouts may not predict long-duration tolerance, yet it provides a more distinct, physically testable second portfolio member with bounded adjustment and release gating.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":5,"contrivance_risk":1,"incremental_portfolio_value":1,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":5},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":3,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":4,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":3,"structural_fidelity":4,"testability":4},"winner":"B"},{"pair_id":"E13Q011","reason":"A instantiates stock-flow control with independently observed physical stock, lawful clearance constraints, target bands, and displacement checks; it complements the appeal-pendency P1. B is structurally strong but is another closely analogous governance-stock ledger, so adds less portfolio breadth.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":5,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":5,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":3,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":4},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":3,"incremental_portfolio_value":2,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":3,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":4},"winner":"A"},{"pair_id":"E13Q009","reason":"A uses genuinely new nondestructive observations to make rival physical-document histories more discriminable while retaining explicitly provisional inference. B is a very clean abduction protocol, but it closely duplicates P1's action-limited public-administration explanation docket.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":5,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":3,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":4},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":5,"contrivance_risk":1,"incremental_portfolio_value":2,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":5},"winner":"A"},{"pair_id":"E13Q032","reason":"B more directly realizes canonical event assertions, competing claims, distinct temporal orders, versioned projections, and replay in a practical digital-humanities form. A is inventive and testable, but its specialized apparatus is burdensome and its physical manipulation trace is only a limited proxy for literary reading.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":3,"contrivance_risk":4,"incremental_portfolio_value":4,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":2,"structural_fidelity":4,"testability":5},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":4,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":3,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":4},"winner":"B"},{"pair_id":"E13Q051","reason":"Both fit the representation-selection archetype, but B cleanly tests whether continuous paired fit margins preserve decision-relevant information lost by bins, while respecting true configuration boundaries. A is well specified but its coating-based field measurement adds more specialized feasibility and interpretation risk.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":3,"incremental_portfolio_value":4,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":3,"structural_fidelity":4,"testability":4},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":5,"contrivance_risk":1,"incremental_portfolio_value":4,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":5,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":5},"winner":"B"},{"pair_id":"E13Q035","reason":"A extends deterioration monitoring from the athlete in P1 to a shared, upstream performance environment, with spatial trend memory, repair linkage, and post-repair verification. B is also excellent but functions more as laboratory quality control and offers slightly less independent portfolio breadth.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":5,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":3,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":4},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":5,"contrivance_risk":1,"incremental_portfolio_value":4,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":5},"winner":"A"}]}