{"judgments":[{"pair_id":"E13Q059","reason":"A is a genuinely complementary physical-evidence instantiation of event primacy, with explicit identity, bitemporality, replay, and falsifiers. B is exceptionally coherent but substantially duplicates P1’s library event-ledger form.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":3,"incremental_portfolio_value":5,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":3,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":5},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":5,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":2,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":5},"winner":"A"},{"pair_id":"E13Q045","reason":"B supplies a natural, bounded agency–structure analysis of literary reception with strong process evidence and counterfactual discipline. A is imaginative and instrumented, but the venue reconstruction and performer substitutions weakly support historical-form attribution.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":3,"contrivance_risk":4,"incremental_portfolio_value":4,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":2,"structural_fidelity":4,"testability":5},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":5,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":4,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":4},"winner":"B"},{"pair_id":"E13Q042","reason":"A directly diagnoses threshold and hysteretic physical decay, then uses bounded physical trials to select a differentiated transition regime. It adds a strong preservation application beyond P1’s catalog-governance transition.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":5,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":5,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":5},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":4,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":4},"winner":"A"},{"pair_id":"E13Q015","reason":"A is a strong direct legal application but remains close to P1’s rulemaking setting. B more usefully extends the restraint pattern into physical facility architecture, preserving a separable core and making capacity and dependency boundaries testable.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":5,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":3,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":4},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":3,"incremental_portfolio_value":5,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":3,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":5},"winner":"B"},{"pair_id":"E13Q046","reason":"A is an unusually exact macro–micro application: a valid room average demonstrably can conceal position-specific failure, and the proposed passive intervention has clear pre/post tests. B is sound but overlaps more with P1’s public-administration setting.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":5,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":5,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":5},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":2,"incremental_portfolio_value":3,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":4},"winner":"A"},{"pair_id":"E13Q043","reason":"A adds a materially grounded, conservator-bounded route to distinguish accumulation, reorganization, and replacement in literary-form history. Its physical evidence cannot settle literary meaning alone, but its uncertainty controls make that limitation explicit; B is more administratively forced around genre categories.","scores_a":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":3,"incremental_portfolio_value":5,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":3,"structural_fidelity":5,"testability":4},"scores_b":{"causal_coherence":4,"contrivance_risk":3,"incremental_portfolio_value":4,"operational_specificity":5,"practicality":4,"structural_fidelity":4,"testability":4},"winner":"A"}]}