{"cases":[{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E14A004__DIRECT","case_type":"DIRECT_POSITIVE","domain":"Contemporary art museum exhibition","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":null,"remedy_leakage_audit":"The statement documents interpretive failures and visitor confusion without proposing changes, guidance, or corrective measures.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"The exhibition repeatedly uses a black key, blue thread, split circle, and silver doorway."},{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Visitors encounter the visual vocabulary across paintings, projections, sculptures, and five galleries."},{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c4","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Visitors must derive kinship, estrangement, memory, authority, and reconciliation from visual details."},{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c5","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"The black key returns in a new gallery with an intended meaning that conflicts with its established association and common expectations."}],"scenario_text":"A contemporary artist’s retrospective spans five galleries containing paintings, projected animations, and small sculptural tableaux. A black key, blue thread, split circle, and silver doorway recur throughout the show. The artist expects visitors to read these details as evidence of kinship, estrangement, inherited memory, and changing authority among the depicted figures. Those readings must carry from early family portraits into later abstract rooms for the exhibition’s implied history to make sense.\n\nThe black key creates particular confusion. In the artist’s earlier work and in familiar folklore, it suggests secrecy, confinement, or forbidden knowledge. In the final gallery, the same key appears enlarged above an open doorway, where the artist intends it to signify permission and reconciliation. Some visitors therefore describe the ending as liberation, while others conclude that the family has entered another form of captivity. Similar shifts affect the blue thread, which alternately seems to mark blood relation, obligation, and emotional distance. Exit interviews show that visitors cannot reliably agree on who is connected, what changed, or whether the final scene is hopeful.","scenario_title":"Conflicting Readings Across a Family Retrospective","vocabulary_separation_audit":"The case uses museum, gallery, folklore, portraiture, and visitor language specific to contemporary art; it does not reproduce any supplied condition sentence or name the target framework."},{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E14A004__TRANSFER","case_type":"TRANSFER_POSITIVE","domain":"Emergency utility fleet dispatch software","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":null,"remedy_leakage_audit":"The statement reports operational misunderstandings and their consequences without suggesting interface revisions, training, or other remedies.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Orange halos, hollow triangles, linked rings, and striped vehicle cards recur throughout the dispatch suite."},{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"The same incident is followed across wall displays, tablets, vehicle terminals, and handoff reports."},{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c4","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Dispatchers infer urgency, responsibility, dependency, and crew readiness from graphical cues."},{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c5","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"An orange halo convention from consumer mapping is reused with a different operational meaning, causing prior expectations to collide."}],"scenario_text":"A regional electric utility tracks storm-response crews through a dispatch suite shown on a control-room wall, supervisor tablets, vehicle terminals, and shift-handoff reports. Orange halos, hollow triangles, linked rings, and diagonally striped vehicle cards recur throughout these displays. Dispatchers are expected to infer incident urgency, crew responsibility, task dependencies, and whether a team is ready to enter a damaged area. A single outage may move through six screens during a shift, so those readings must remain intelligible as ownership and status change.\n\nThe orange halo is producing incompatible interpretations. In consumer mapping tools used by most employees, a halo commonly marks the user’s current position or a selected location. Here, designers use it around a substation to mean that an electrical hazard boundary is active. On the wall display, some operators treat the haloed station as the current focus rather than a restricted site. The linked-ring mark also reads as either cooperating crews or physically connected circuits, depending on the screen. During recent drills, supervisors formed different accounts of which crew controlled an incident and whether entry had been authorized, even though they viewed the same underlying record.","scenario_title":"Storm Dispatch Displays Yield Conflicting Operational Readings","vocabulary_separation_audit":"The transfer case uses utility operations, dispatch, outage, crew, and substation terminology, sharply separating it from the museum case while avoiding the supplied predicate wording and target name."},{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E14A004__NEAR_MISS","case_type":"ONE_LITERAL_NEAR_MISS","domain":"Municipal water-treatment operations software","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":"b066_a14_c1","remedy_leakage_audit":"The statement confines itself to observed ambiguity, workflow requirements, and consequences; it contains no proposed correction or intervention.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c1","intended_status":"CONTRADICTED","scenario_evidence":"The suite explicitly has no repeated mark, color treatment, shape, pictogram, or figurative device; every visual cue occurs only once."},{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Operators must maintain a coherent interpretation of one event across intake, laboratory, pump-control, supervisor, and compliance views."},{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c4","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Staff infer responsibility, severity, causal relationships, and approval state from the separate visual cues."},{"condition_id":"b066_a14_c5","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"A crown-shaped badge borrowed from a vendor certification seal is used once in the new system with a conflicting intended meaning."}],"scenario_text":"A municipal water authority follows contamination events through separate intake, laboratory, pump-control, supervisor, and compliance screens. Operators must carry one coherent account of severity, causal relationships, responsibility, and approval state across the entire workflow. Each view communicates those facts mainly through its own visual details, including placement, border weight, diagram proximity, and one-off pictograms.\n\nThe suite has no repeated graphic vocabulary: no mark, color treatment, shape, pictogram, or figurative device appears more than once, and each screen was commissioned independently. Even so, a single crown-shaped badge on the compliance view is causing a specific clash. It was borrowed from a laboratory vendor’s longstanding certification seal, which staff and regulators associate with externally audited approval. In the municipal screen, the badge is intended to mean that a sample is awaiting manual review. Because the event’s meaning must remain coherent from the intake alert through the final report, viewers use that isolated badge to infer whether the result is authoritative. During a recent exercise, laboratory staff described the sample as pending while supervisors and regulators read the same record as already certified.","scenario_title":"Independent Water-System Screens Produce an Approval Dispute","vocabulary_separation_audit":"The near miss retains a technical operations setting comparable in difficulty to the transfer case but switches to water treatment and compliance language. It explicitly excludes recurrence while avoiding copied predicates and framework terminology."}],"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp14_applicability_retrieval40_20260813","sample_id":"E14A004","schema_version":1}