{"cases":[{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E14A013__DIRECT","case_type":"DIRECT_POSITIVE","domain":"Industrial instrument calibration services","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":null,"remedy_leakage_audit":"The statement presents commercial tensions, operational capabilities, and constraints without proposing an intervention or naming the underlying approach.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Customers range from routine-maintenance teams to plants facing urgent shutdowns and regulated audits."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Turnaround, documentation, collection, consultation, and loan-equipment access are separable aspects of the service."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c4","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Charging according to inferred customer identity would be objectionable, unreliable, and manipulable."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c5","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Barcoded work orders, reserved capacity, and portal permissions can reliably enforce purchased service entitlements while preserving identical calibration accuracy."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c6","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Distinct groups primarily value speed, audit assistance, logistics, or expert availability beyond the core measurement."}],"scenario_text":"A regional laboratory calibrates pressure gauges and flow meters for manufacturers. Some customers schedule routine maintenance months ahead and mainly want a valid certificate at low cost. Plants facing an unexpected shutdown will pay much more for overnight turnaround, while regulated facilities care most about detailed audit records and access to an engineer who can answer an inspector’s questions. Others prize scheduled collection, a loan instrument, or permission to change the job queue after submission. One uniform fee has become awkward: a high fee drives routine work to competitors, but a low fee leaves scarce rush capacity and specialist time underfunded. The laboratory cannot responsibly set charges by guessing a customer’s industry, plant size, or apparent desperation; those signals are unreliable, invite strategic misrepresentation, and would create compliance concerns. Its workflow already separates turnaround commitments, documentation depth, collection windows, consultation time, and loan-equipment access. Barcoded work orders, capacity reservations, and portal permissions can reliably honor those distinctions, while every completed calibration retains the same required accuracy and safety standard.","scenario_title":"Calibration Laboratory Caught Between Routine and Urgent Work","vocabulary_separation_audit":"This case uses industrial metrology, audit, workflow, and plant-maintenance vocabulary, distinct from the maritime passenger setting of the transfer cases."},{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E14A013__TRANSFER","case_type":"TRANSFER_POSITIVE","domain":"Inter-island passenger ferry operations","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":null,"remedy_leakage_audit":"The statement describes demand variation and existing operating constraints only; it neither recommends a pricing design nor describes a solution archetype.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Island residents, tourists, contractors, and disrupted travelers display materially different urgency, flexibility, and service needs."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Booking flexibility, boarding sequence, seating areas, baggage allowances, and onboard amenities are separable."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c4","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Identity-based fares would be contentious and residency or trip-purpose claims could be borrowed or fabricated."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c5","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Reservation records, gate scanners, marked areas, and crew procedures can administer distinctions without withholding safe passage."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c6","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Passengers variously prioritize change rights, dependable boarding, work space, baggage capacity, or quiet over the basic crossing."}],"scenario_text":"An inter-island ferry operator serves residents making planned errands, tourists with flexible itineraries, contractors carrying equipment, and travelers trying to reach a same-day flight after weather disruptions. All receive the same basic crossing, yet their priorities differ sharply. Some care almost entirely about the lowest fare; others care more about changing departures, being certain they can board a busy sailing, carrying extra bags, finding a quiet seat, or using a table and reliable power during the trip. The current single fare either feels excessive to flexible residents or fails to reflect the operational burden and urgency associated with other journeys. Setting fares after judging a passenger’s identity or stated purpose would be contentious and unreliable: residency credentials can be borrowed, and anyone can claim an urgent appointment. The reservation system can separately record change rights, baggage allowances, boarding sequence, and access to marked seating areas. Existing gate scanners and onboard checks can administer those distinctions with little delay, while ordinary ticket holders still receive safe transportation, standard seating, and required accessibility assistance.","scenario_title":"One Ferry Fare for Passengers with Very Different Priorities","vocabulary_separation_audit":"The maritime setting and passenger concepts differ substantially from the direct case's industrial calibration language; no metrology, manufacturing, or laboratory framing is reused."},{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E14A013__NEAR_MISS","case_type":"ONE_LITERAL_NEAR_MISS","domain":"Inter-island passenger ferry operations","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":"b071_a12_c5","remedy_leakage_audit":"The statement remains diagnostic and explicitly reports an operational impossibility; it does not recommend an intervention or disclose the archetype.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"The same mix of residents, tourists, contractors, and disrupted travelers has sharply different urgency and flexibility."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Change rights, boarding order, baggage, seating environment, and workspace remain conceptually separable."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c4","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Identity or claimed-purpose pricing remains inappropriate, unverifiable, and gameable."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c5","intended_status":"CONTRADICTED","scenario_evidence":"The vessel, terminal, ticketing system, and staffing cannot police differentiated entitlements without severe delays, onboard disputes, and accessibility harms."},{"condition_id":"b071_a12_c6","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Different passengers still value flexibility, boarding certainty, baggage handling, quiet, or workspace more than the crossing itself."}],"scenario_text":"An inter-island ferry operator serves residents making planned errands, tourists with flexible itineraries, contractors carrying equipment, and travelers trying to reach a same-day flight after weather disruptions. Some passengers mainly want the cheapest safe crossing. Others care far more about departure changes, certainty of boarding, extra baggage, a quiet place, or a table and power for working en route. The single fare remains a poor fit for this spread of priorities. Charging according to residency, occupation, or a claimed reason for travel would be contentious and easy to manipulate because documents are commonly shared and urgent stories cannot be verified. Although booking flexibility, boarding order, luggage handling, and seating environment are distinguishable parts of the trip, the operator cannot reliably police separate entitlements. The old vessel has one open cabin with unnumbered seats, the terminal funnels everyone through a single manual gate, and paper tickets cannot encode permissions. Additional checks would create missed sailings and onboard disputes; restricting cabin areas would also obstruct the only accessible route to the restroom. Current staffing cannot avoid those consequences.","scenario_title":"Ferry Differences That the Terminal Cannot Reliably Administer","vocabulary_separation_audit":"The near miss deliberately retains the transfer case's maritime vocabulary and difficulty for controlled comparison, while remaining clearly separated from the industrial direct case."}],"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp14_applicability_retrieval40_20260813","sample_id":"E14A013","schema_version":1}