{"cases":[{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E14A014__DIRECT","case_type":"DIRECT_POSITIVE","domain":"Electric-grid incident monitoring","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":null,"remedy_leakage_audit":"The statement describes operational requirements and failure pressures without proposing a design, intervention, or implementation.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"The utility has thousands of event signatures, while a typical disturbance involves only three to eight."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Dispatchers must identify the relevant signatures within seconds and cannot inspect every absent signature."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c3","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Rare disturbances are distinguished by different combinations drawn from recurring signatures."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c4","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Processing and displaying the entire catalog causes latency, bandwidth consumption, and operator overload."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c6","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"A permanent shortlist fails because relevant signatures vary by equipment, weather, topology, and failure sequence."}],"scenario_text":"A regional electric utility monitors fault episodes from 80,000 field devices. Its engineering catalog contains roughly 6,000 event signatures covering relay behavior, voltage excursions, weather exposure, equipment condition, and network topology. A typical disturbance involves only three to eight signatures, but the relevant ones vary widely from one episode to another. Dispatchers must see which conditions apply within seconds; inspecting a record containing every absent signature delays decisions during cascading failures. Rare but consequential events are often distinguished by a particular combination of otherwise familiar signatures, so broad labels such as “line fault” or “transformer issue” erase distinctions needed for routing crews and assessing risk. When the monitoring pipeline evaluates and transmits the full catalog for every device report, control-room screens lag, radio links saturate, and operators overlook important details. A permanent shortlist also performs poorly: coastal storms, urban cable failures, rural vegetation contacts, and substation protection errors each make different parts of the catalog relevant.","scenario_title":"Overloaded Grid-Disturbance Records","vocabulary_separation_audit":"Uses power-system telemetry, relay, topology, dispatch, and field-device vocabulary, distinct from the natural-history collection vocabulary of the transfer cases."},{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E14A014__TRANSFER","case_type":"TRANSFER_POSITIVE","domain":"Natural-history specimen cataloging","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":null,"remedy_leakage_audit":"The statement presents cataloging constraints and observed failures only; it does not recommend a schema, interface, algorithm, or workflow change.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"The consortium maintains 18,000 descriptors, but an individual specimen normally needs only two to seven."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Researchers and collection staff need immediate access to the applicable descriptors without traversing thousands of empty fields."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c3","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Scientifically meaningful distinctions depend on varied combinations of recurring descriptors."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c4","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Materializing the entire vocabulary per record sharply increases index size, synchronization time, screen clutter, and review burden."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c6","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"No fixed descriptor panel works across fossils, insects, plants, tissue samples, and minerals."}],"scenario_text":"A consortium is merging records for twelve million natural-history specimens collected over 140 years. Its controlled vocabulary includes about 18,000 descriptors for preservation state, anatomy, collection circumstances, geological context, preparation method, and legal restrictions. Most specimens need only two to seven descriptors, yet those details must be immediately visible to researchers planning loans and to staff handling fragile material. Scientifically distinct records frequently depend on different combinations of recurring observations: the same preparation method may matter differently when paired with a particular tissue condition, collecting environment, or permit status. Materializing the entire vocabulary for every specimen has made search indexes enormous, handheld synchronization slow, and catalog screens difficult to review. Replacing the vocabulary with a few broad specimen classes loses distinctions used in comparative studies and handling decisions. Nor does one fixed panel of favored descriptors cover the collection: fossils, pinned insects, pressed plants, frozen tissue, and mineral samples each draw attention to different portions of the vocabulary, with substantial variation even within those groups.","scenario_title":"Unwieldy Museum Specimen Records","vocabulary_separation_audit":"Recasts all route conditions through museum collections, preservation, anatomy, loans, and permits; it shares no grid-operational terminology with the direct case."},{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E14A014__NEAR_MISS","case_type":"ONE_LITERAL_NEAR_MISS","domain":"Natural-history specimen handling codes","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":"b064_a05_c3","remedy_leakage_audit":"The statement diagnoses code-selection and display burdens without suggesting how the coding system should be redesigned or implemented.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"There are 18,000 possible handling codes, while each specimen legitimately carries only one."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Handlers must retrieve the applicable code immediately without scanning thousands of unused entries."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c3","intended_status":"CONTRADICTED","scenario_evidence":"The standard explicitly requires one indivisible code per specimen; combinations are invalid and convey no additional meaning."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c4","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Legacy records with many simultaneous codes cause sharp growth in packet size, synchronization delay, display clutter, and handling ambiguity."},{"condition_id":"b064_a05_c6","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"A universal shortlist cannot replace the full codebook because the correct single code varies across specimens and jurisdictions."}],"scenario_text":"The same natural-history consortium also maintains an 18,000-entry codebook for specimen-handling restrictions. Under the governing standard, every specimen receives exactly one indivisible code chosen for its controlling hazard or legal constraint. Combining codes is explicitly invalid: readers are not expected to infer meaning from pairs or groups, and a multi-code record fails validation rather than describing a more specific case. Loan officers and handlers nevertheless need to retrieve the applicable code immediately, without searching thousands of irrelevant entries. The burden becomes severe when imported legacy records mistakenly carry dozens of codes; handheld packets expand sharply, synchronization stalls, labels become cluttered, and staff cannot tell which instruction controls. A short universal list cannot substitute for the codebook because the correct code changes with preservation chemicals, biosecurity status, cultural-property rules, radiation history, and destination jurisdiction. Thus only one entry matters for any specimen, but which entry matters varies substantially across the collection, and exposing many entries at once creates significant operational cost.","scenario_title":"Single-Code Specimen Restrictions","vocabulary_separation_audit":"Retains the transfer domain and comparable scale, users, and operational pressures while shifting from descriptive observations to mutually exclusive regulatory codes; it remains lexically separate from the electric-grid case."}],"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp14_applicability_retrieval40_20260813","sample_id":"E14A014","schema_version":1}