{"candidates":[{"best_route_status":"CONTRADICTED","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C01","confidence":0.94,"reason":"The evidence establishes robust normal-load performance rather than a brittle, overprotected system.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C01R01L01","evidence":"Full-normal-load trials, reserve capacity, independent confirmation, and the explicit conclusion oppose a mistaken inference from immediate performance.","status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C01R01L02","evidence":"The biofilter recovered after damage and now has a mature nitrifying population.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C01R01L03","evidence":"No adaptation-versus-injury dose window is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C01R01L04","evidence":"The scenario does not establish that gains require repeated exposure, variation, progression, and recovery.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C01R01L05","evidence":"Continuous monitoring and three full-load trials with reserve capacity contradict an under-practiced or easy-metric environment.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C01R01","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"}]},{"best_route_status":"CONTRADICTED","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C02","confidence":0.89,"reason":"The normal-load trials showed no water-quality rebound or accumulating nitrogen waste.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C02R01L01","evidence":"The scenario does not establish the specified repeating process cycle.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C02R01L02","evidence":"Ammonia and nitrite remained below detection limits and no rebound occurred under full-load trials.","status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C02R01L03","evidence":"Trials at the normal population and ration remained stable with reserve capacity.","status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C02R01L04","evidence":"No claimed closed-loop boundary or external cleanup dependency is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C02R01L05","evidence":"No comparison framework to current practice or theoretical limits is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C02R01","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03","confidence":0.94,"reason":"No repeated-reset pattern is established; all routes requiring undesirable stable-state geometry are contradicted by successful full-load restoration evidence.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R01L01","evidence":"Only one outage and recovery are described; repeated resets reverting to the same pattern are not established.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R02L01","evidence":"No evidence concerns small starting-state differences producing different long-run outcomes.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R02L02","evidence":"Full-load trials and the explicit conclusion support reliable return to normal operation, not inability to enter or retain a preferred state.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R02","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R03L01","evidence":"No organization or population convention is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R03L02","evidence":"Full-load trials and the explicit conclusion support reliable return to normal operation, not inability to enter or retain a preferred state.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R03","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R04L01","evidence":"No differing recovery and decline thresholds are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R04L02","evidence":"Full-load trials and the explicit conclusion support reliable return to normal operation, not inability to enter or retain a preferred state.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R04","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R05L01","evidence":"No multiple optima, cycles, regimes, or self-reinforcing equilibria are established.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R05L02","evidence":"Full-load trials and the explicit conclusion support reliable return to normal operation, not inability to enter or retain a preferred state.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R05","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R06L01","evidence":"No desired state's basin is described as small or inaccessible.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R06L02","evidence":"Full-load trials and the explicit conclusion support reliable return to normal operation, not inability to enter or retain a preferred state.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R06","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R07L01","evidence":"No harmful state is shown to be easy to enter or hard to leave after the repaired biofilter was tested.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R07L02","evidence":"Full-load trials and the explicit conclusion support reliable return to normal operation, not inability to enter or retain a preferred state.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C03R07","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"}]},{"best_route_status":"CONTRADICTED","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C04","confidence":0.86,"reason":"The system has recovered to its documented pre-outage biological state and demonstrated stable normal-load operation.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C04R01L01","evidence":"The biofilter is at pre-outage density and water-quality indicators are stable, rather than drifting away from the reference.","status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C04R01L02","evidence":"No evidence states that delay causes irreversible loss while intervention risks damage or evidence loss.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C04R01L03","evidence":"The pre-outage reference is directly specified and supported by monitoring and laboratory confirmation.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C04R01","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"}]},{"best_route_status":"CONTRADICTED","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C05","confidence":0.99,"reason":"Biologists explicitly conclude that immediate full restoration cannot recreate the outage-related failure mode.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C05R01L01","evidence":"The explicit biological conclusion says immediate restoration of normal biomass and ration cannot reproduce ammonia accumulation, oxygen loss, or mortality.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C05R01","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C06","confidence":0.98,"reason":"The scenario contains no delayed or distance-dependent signal transmission problem.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C06R01L01","evidence":"No decision is described as depending on a signal after delay or distance.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C06R01L02","evidence":"No weak-region or later-time receivers are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C06R01L03","evidence":"No differing signal-component decay rates are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C06R01L04","evidence":"No source-versus-endpoint signal degradation pattern is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C06R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C07","confidence":0.92,"reason":"Recovery after the outage is described, but the required recurring-demand, delayed-overload, and sustainable-envelope structure is not established.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C07R01L01","evidence":"The damaged biofilter later recovered, but a finite support substrate with the stated renewal/degradation structure is not established.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C07R01L02","evidence":"Normal full-load demand was tested, but recurring demand is not separately measured against one-time peak demand.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C07R01L03","evidence":"No evidence shows short-term operation exceeding sustainable levels by consuming reserves or slack.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C07R01L04","evidence":"No delayed overload harm, hysteresis, or accumulated drawdown is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C07R01L05","evidence":"No relative cadence of regeneration and demand growth is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C07R01L06","evidence":"No threshold breach is masked by reserves or shifted burdens.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C07R01L07","evidence":"No comparison of restoration cost with staying within a sustainable envelope is provided.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C07R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C08","confidence":0.98,"reason":"No bounded developmental or state-dependent acquisition window is evidenced.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C08R01L01","evidence":"No longitudinal, mechanistic, or comparative evidence of time- or state-varying acquisition effects is given.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C08R01L02","evidence":"No target configuration requiring experience, cues, practice, interaction, or treatment is established.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C08R01L03","evidence":"No opening or closing interval is estimated.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C08R01L04","evidence":"No durable disadvantage from missing an interval is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C08R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C09","confidence":0.97,"reason":"The scenario does not establish reinforcing overshoot or a shared clearance-capacity unwind.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C09R01L01","evidence":"No rapid reinforcing growth or delayed-feedback overshoot is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C09R01L02","evidence":"No growing stock is described as later converting into material clearance work.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C09R01L03","evidence":"No primary support and secondary clearance capacities are specified as finite or slow.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C09R01L04","evidence":"No common unwind or tail-correlated clearance peak is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C09R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C10","confidence":0.98,"reason":"No product lifecycle, post-use material path, or circularity claim is described.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C10R01L01","evidence":"No point-of-sale or operational lifecycle impacts are described as invisible.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C10R01L02","evidence":"No post-use material path is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C10R01L03","evidence":"No circularity claim or burden shift is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C10R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C11","confidence":0.99,"reason":"No multi-institutional filtering process or hidden output universe is described.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C11R01L01","evidence":"No independent institutions, roles, or rules acting as output filters are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C11R01L02","evidence":"No candidate-output universe beyond visible survivors is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C11R01L03","evidence":"No implicit or incentive-driven filter criteria are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C11R01L04","evidence":"No producers adapting to expected filters are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C11R01L05","evidence":"No recipients or unobserved discarded output are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C11R01L06","evidence":"No nominally distinct filters are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C11R01L07","evidence":"No quality, viewpoint, or status filtering is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C11R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C12","confidence":0.99,"reason":"No new population or lineage with a narrow founding gate is described.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C12R01L01","evidence":"No new population or lineage beginning from fewer sources is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C12R01L02","evidence":"No narrow admission, migration, procurement, recruitment, copying, or survival gate is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C12R01L03","evidence":"No early members and descendants, norms, templates, data, or infrastructure lineage is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C12R01L04","evidence":"No descendant composition predicted by an origin cohort is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C12R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"SATISFIED","candidate_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C13","confidence":0.88,"reason":"The operational conclusion relies on specified biological and monitoring conditions, has been independently verified, and supports normal-scale production decisions.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C13R01L01","evidence":"The conclusion depends on biofilter maturity, fish biomass, feed ration, water-quality monitoring, pump and aeration condition, and supervised trials.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C13R01L02","evidence":"An independent aquatic laboratory verified the findings.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C13R01L03","evidence":"The trial result is being used to decide whether to resume ordinary stocking and feeding at normal production scale.","status":"SATISFIED"}],"route_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919C13R01","route_status":"SATISFIED"}]}],"opaque_case_id":"E14Q7080F38DD919"}