{"candidates":[{"best_route_status":"CONTRADICTED","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC01","confidence":0.98,"reason":"The task explicitly improves the violation count rather than preserving an unchanged state.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC01R01L01","evidence":"No bounded accessibility interval is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC01R01L02","evidence":"No predictable fading, expiration, cooling, or overwrite is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC01R01L03","evidence":"The scenario does not establish a repeated maintenance action that reasserts a state.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC01R01L04","evidence":"Each admissible swap is made only when it reduces rule violations, so the task is improvement rather than preservation.","status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC01R01L05","evidence":"No detection of lapse, staleness, or drift is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC01R01","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC02","confidence":0.98,"reason":"The scenario provides no evidence of chunked processing, recombination, topology-dependent results, or reporting rollups.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC02R01L01","evidence":"No chunking, sharding, hierarchy, or partitioned input processing is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC02R01L02","evidence":"No merging of partial results is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC02R01L03","evidence":"No deployment-topology or worker-count comparison is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC02R01L04","evidence":"No recombination process or lost summary state is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC02R01L05","evidence":"No reporting hierarchy or rollup requirement is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC02R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC03","confidence":0.97,"reason":"The evidence establishes time-limited search sensitivity to initialization, but not an anomalous case relative to an expected comparison outcome.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC03R01L01","evidence":"No expected outcome, benchmark, or ordinary-case association is stated as violated.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC03R01L02","evidence":"No comparison universe of ordinary versus focal cases is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC03R01L03","evidence":"No existing explanation for typical cases is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC03R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC04","confidence":0.99,"reason":"No multi-participant decision protocol, failures, partitions, persistence mechanism, or changing membership is described.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC04R01L01","evidence":"No participants jointly proposing or acknowledging a decision are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC04R01L02","evidence":"No independently deciding correct participants are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC04R01L03","evidence":"No participant or communication-path failures are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC04R01L04","evidence":"No retry, leadership change, recovery, or required decision persistence is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC04R01L05","evidence":"No partition or availability-versus-consistency tradeoff is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC04R01L06","evidence":"No membership changes, votes, or log evidence are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC04R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC05","confidence":0.98,"reason":"The scenario does not establish multiple locally tolerated deviations, integration mismatch, downstream rework, or compounding local choices.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC05R01L01","evidence":"Several locally tolerated deviation sources are not described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC05R01L02","evidence":"No evidence shows locally passing contributors whose integrated outcome fails.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC05R01L03","evidence":"No downstream-team mismatch, rework, or exception pattern is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC05R01L04","evidence":"No compounding sequence of small local deviations is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC05R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"CONTRADICTED","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC06","confidence":0.99,"reason":"The eligibility, availability, coverage, and rest constraints are fixed before each run, and the authoritative objective is fixed.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC06R01L01","evidence":"The target conditions are fixed before each run; no materially moving target is described.","status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC06R01L02","evidence":"Target updates with uncertain timing, authority, provenance, or effective date are not present; the inputs are fixed before each run.","status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC06R01L03","evidence":"No moving environment or changing input-outcome relation is described; the records and rule set are fixed for the runs.","status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC06R01L04","evidence":"No moving target exists for sensing or actuation bandwidth to lag.","status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC06R01L05","evidence":"There is one authoritative violation count and no differing adoption cadences for a moving objective.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC06R01","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC07","confidence":0.99,"reason":"No nested contexts, suspension and resumption, or last-opened-first-closed structure is described.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC07R01L01","evidence":"No strictly nested actions, calls, permissions, resources, or contexts are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC07R01L02","evidence":"No child opening that suspends and later resumes a parent is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC07R01L03","evidence":"No frame-closing order is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC07R01L04","evidence":"No active-top or next-resuming context is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC07R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC08","confidence":0.98,"reason":"Although assignment constraints are fixed before a run, the scenario does not establish a check-use gap, intervening state change, resulting harm, or a guarding mechanism.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC08R01L01","evidence":"The scenario does not state that a later action depends on a specifically earlier precondition check or lookup.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC08R01L02","evidence":"Eligibility, availability, room coverage, and rest requirements are stated to be fixed before each run, but no check-use state transition is specified.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC08R01L03","evidence":"No delay, handoff, queue, callback, or other check-to-action interval is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC08R01L04","evidence":"No false acceptance following a state change is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC08R01L05","evidence":"No version marker, lease, lock, reservation, final recheck, or abort rule is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC08R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC09","confidence":0.99,"reason":"No repeatedly retrieved trace, habit, activation event, or correction introduced during activation is described.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC09R01L01","evidence":"No stored narrative, belief, routine, association, classification, or response is described as repeatedly retrieved.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC09R01L02","evidence":"No stable trace, habit, interpretation, or record reasserting when cued is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC09R01L03","evidence":"No recall, rehearsal, use, simulation, incident review, case discussion, or live lookup activation moment is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC09R01L04","evidence":"No correction or alternative association introduced while an active target pattern is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC09R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC10","confidence":0.98,"reason":"The scenario describes iterative local search, not a population or item stream moving through ordered outcome stages.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC10R01L01","evidence":"No population or item stream passing through ordered stages is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC10R01L02","evidence":"The runs end with violation counts, but no expected final yield, conversion, retention, throughput, or quality metric is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC10R01L03","evidence":"The audit trail records swaps, not entry, exit, abandonment, reentry, or transition events for ordered stages.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC10R01L04","evidence":"No stage-specific improvement or downstream attrition is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC10R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC11","confidence":0.99,"reason":"No queue, service classes, backlog behavior, routing, or class-specific metrics are described.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC11R01L01","evidence":"No queue mixing different service requirements or times is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC11R01L02","evidence":"No eligible class delaying or crowding out another is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC11R01L03","evidence":"No urgent or safety-sensitive queue items are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC11R01L04","evidence":"No simple work waiting behind complex work is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC11R01L05","evidence":"No specialized work or service paths are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC11R01L06","evidence":"No blocked or exception cases stalling routine flow are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC11R01L07","evidence":"No aggregate service metrics or class-specific failures are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC11R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC12","confidence":0.94,"reason":"Rooms and invigilators support identifiable sites and constrained assignment, but vacancy, release, and turnover states are not established.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC12R01L01","evidence":"The scenario assigns changing invigilators to examination rooms, which remain identified as rooms.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC12R01L02","evidence":"Room coverage is a fixed assignment constraint independent of a particular invigilator.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC12R01L03","evidence":"Assignment is described, but vacancy, release, and turnover are not described as operational states.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC12R01L04","evidence":"Invigilator assignments are governed by fixed eligibility, availability, coverage, and rest constraints.","status":"SATISFIED"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC12R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"CONTRADICTED","candidate_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC13","confidence":0.99,"reason":"Initialization affects how far the search progresses before a time cutoff, but exhaustive audit evidence rules out local traps, plateaus, and required non-local moves; the objective is a single authoritative count.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC13R01L01","evidence":"For every encountered nonminimum timetable, the audit found an admissible single swap reducing violations; longer replays reached the same minimum, so no local-improvement stall is established.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC13R01","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC13R02L01","evidence":"Starting from last year's timetable left 38 violations at the cutoff, while the hand-built starting timetable left 7 under identical deterministic conditions.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC13R02L02","evidence":"The audit found no flat stretches or dead ends, no worsening move was needed, and longer replays from both starts reached the same minimum.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC13R02","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC13R03L01","evidence":"The registrar uses one authoritative violation count, with no secondary targets or surrogate scores.","status":"CONTRADICTED"}],"route_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796DC13R03","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"}]}],"opaque_case_id":"E14Q8AB3B178796D"}