{"candidates":[{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C01","confidence":0.99,"reason":"The scenario supplies no evidence of serial defensive layers, their dependence, or cross-layer safety failures.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C01R01L01","evidence":"No serial defensive layers are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C01R01L02","evidence":"No defensive-layer bypass or degradation probabilities are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C01R01L03","evidence":"No failure dependence among defensive layers is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C01R01L04","evidence":"No nominal safety-layer claim is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C01R01L05","evidence":"No incident involving nominal controls failing along a hazard trajectory is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C01R01L06","evidence":"No distributed ownership of defensive layers is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C01R01L07","evidence":"No rare catastrophic aligned defensive-layer failure is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C01R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C02","confidence":0.97,"reason":"The event record was reconstructed and overwritten, but material capture delay and interpretation of silence as nonoccurrence are not established.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C02R01L01","evidence":"The scenario does not establish a material delay between occurrence and first capture.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C02R01L02","evidence":"The contractor created a later consensus chronology from event materials used in the case file.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C02R01L03","evidence":"Original timestamps and method identifiers were discarded, conflicting observations were invalidated, and discarded material is unrecoverable.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C02R01L04","evidence":"The materials have explicitly different weaknesses, including resolution limits, electronic-state limits, obscured defects, and shifting recollections.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C02R01L05","evidence":"No statement treats missing or silent evidence as proof that no event occurred.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C02R01L06","evidence":"Investigators received a consensus chronology created after the grounding.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C02R01L07","evidence":"Passenger and crew recollections shift after the frightening evacuation.","status":"SATISFIED"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C02R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C03","confidence":0.95,"reason":"Sources were merged and source cues lost, but fluency-as-evidence and downstream consequences are not explicit.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C03R01L01","evidence":"The contractor converted every input into one consensus chronology.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C03R01L02","evidence":"The distinct source types have different stated weaknesses.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C03R01L03","evidence":"Original timestamps and method identifiers were discarded.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C03R01L04","evidence":"The scenario does not state that fluency is treated as evidence.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C03R01L05","evidence":"No downstream consequence of an information error is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C03R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C04","confidence":0.99,"reason":"Separate evidence channels are present, but no feature-binding ambiguity between candidate objects or episodes is established.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C04R01L01","evidence":"Sonar, telemetry, hull inspection, and recollections are separate evidence channels.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C04R01L02","evidence":"No two candidate objects or episodes are stated to share observed features.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C04R01L03","evidence":"No need to recover a correct feature bundle rather than individual features is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C04R01L04","evidence":"No individually correct features are stated to be assigned to a wrong object or episode.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C04R01L05","evidence":"No binding cue is identified.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C04R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C05","confidence":0.94,"reason":"Record provenance matters to the investigative conclusion, but the remaining event-history structure is not established.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C05R01L01","evidence":"The contractor's transformations and discarded originals materially affect the authority's causal conclusion.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C05R01L02","evidence":"No independent entity-centric records or reconciliation process is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C05R01L03","evidence":"No requirement concerning corrections, late evidence, retractions, or prior-state preservation is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C05R01L04","evidence":"No recurring participants, roles, locations, or transformations requiring nonstatic representation are established.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C05R01L05","evidence":"No partial or source-local temporal ordering, or distinction from causal order, is established.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C05R01L06","evidence":"No rebuildable derived current-state view is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C05R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C06","confidence":0.99,"reason":"The scenario does not establish output requirements, acceptance tolerances, or an escaped defect.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C06R01L01","evidence":"No explicit output requirement is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C06R01L02","evidence":"No declared acceptance tolerance or process variation moving an output outside it is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C06R01L03","evidence":"No escaped defect and resulting downstream harm, rework, delay, or trust loss is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C06R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C07","confidence":0.98,"reason":"The authority is answering a case, but no comparable prior-case store or irreducibly detailed comparison configuration is supplied.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C07R01L01","evidence":"The authority reaches a final causal conclusion in an investigation case.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C07R01L02","evidence":"No store of prior cases is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C07R01L03","evidence":"No judgment detail configuration resisting a compact rule is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C07R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"SATISFIED","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C08","confidence":0.91,"reason":"The authority relies on indirectly observed accounts with systematic normalization distortion, varying reliability, and a chronology no longer anchored to source timing.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C08R01L01","evidence":"The authority relies on sonar, telemetry, inspection, and recollections to determine a past event it cannot directly inspect.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C08R01L02","evidence":"The contractor systematically normalized all inputs, discarded timestamps and method identifiers, and invalidated conflicts.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C08R01L03","evidence":"The materials retain information, though each separately leaves substantial doubt.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C08R01L04","evidence":"Different materials have explicitly different weaknesses.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C08R01L05","evidence":"The retained consensus chronology lacks original timestamps and excludes conflicting observations, so its sequence/framing cannot be checked against source event structure.","status":"SATISFIED"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C08R01","route_status":"SATISFIED"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C09","confidence":0.96,"reason":"The conclusion depends on particular evidence inputs, but a need for later verification or challenge is not established.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C09R01L01","evidence":"The final conclusion depends on sonar, telemetry, hull inspection, recollections, and the contractor's processing choices.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C09R01L02","evidence":"No later verifier, rerunner, reviewer, or maintainer need is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C09R01L03","evidence":"No challenge, replication, scaling, transfer, automation, or precedent use is stated.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C09R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"SATISFIED","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C10","confidence":0.99,"reason":"All conditions are explicit: heterogeneous methods, shared upstream telemetry and copying, lost diagnostic disagreement, and unjustified certainty.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C10R01L01","evidence":"Sonar, telemetry, hull inspection, and recollections observe different features and have different stated weaknesses.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C10R01L02","evidence":"Three assessments use the same contractor-normalized telemetry file, and two publications repeat the first assessment's sequence.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C10R01L03","evidence":"The scenario states that discarded disagreement could have revealed limits, distortion, incompatible facts, or overlooked circumstances.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C10R01L04","evidence":"The authority calls sabotage certain although each material considered separately leaves substantial doubt.","status":"SATISFIED"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C10R01","route_status":"SATISFIED"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C11","confidence":0.98,"reason":"Metadata was discarded, but no repeated measurable production signature is described.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C11R01L01","evidence":"No repeated measurable features attributable to a production process, sensor, medium, or transformation are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C11R01L02","evidence":"Original timestamps and method identifiers were discarded and are unrecoverable.","status":"SATISFIED"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C11R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C12","confidence":0.98,"reason":"A hull was inspected in dry dock, but the multiple-independent-inspector conditions are absent.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C12R01L01","evidence":"A dry-dock hull inspection concerns a bounded physical artifact available for inspection.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C12R01L02","evidence":"No individual-inspector blind-spot risk is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C12R01L03","evidence":"No independent inspector framing arrangement is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C12R01L04","evidence":"No differing inspector expertise or blind-spot profiles are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C12R01L05","evidence":"No shared coordination layer for inspector findings is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C12R01L06","evidence":"No overlapping inspection coverage rationale is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C12R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C13","confidence":0.99,"reason":"The scenario concerns causal attribution, not recovery of an item's physical origin from source-dependent signatures.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C13R01L01","evidence":"No origin or source contribution after transport, storage, transformation, copying, mixing, or exchange must be recovered.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C13R01L02","evidence":"No external origin labels, custody records, ledgers, or testimony are stated to be unavailable or unreliable for origin recovery.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C13R01L03","evidence":"No stable measurable source-dependent item property is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C13R01L04","evidence":"No reference library of source signatures is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C13R01L05","evidence":"No probabilistic source-origin inference from a measured signature is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8C13R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]}],"opaque_case_id":"E14QE36AEA1553D8"}