{"candidates":[{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C01","confidence":0.99,"reason":"The scenario provides no evidence about replica convergence, conflicts, tombstones, or recovery contracts.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C01R01L01","evidence":"The scenario describes game-tactic spread and telemetry, not replica contracts.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C01R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C02","confidence":0.98,"reason":"The scenario does not establish a population proxy or a need for one in decision-making.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C02R01L01","evidence":"Communities vary, but they are not stated to be too broad, heterogeneous, or uncertain for direct working-memory reasoning.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C02R01L02","evidence":"No concrete stand-in for a population is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C02R01L03","evidence":"Telemetry is available to analysts; it is not stated to be nonportable into the decision context.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C02R01L04","evidence":"No population proxy or material uncertainty in one is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C02R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C03","confidence":0.99,"reason":"Spread from a small player group is described, but no scale-up justification or cross-scale rule transfer is established.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C03R01L01","evidence":"The tactic began in a small group, but that result is not being used to justify scale-up.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C03R01L02","evidence":"No aggregate rule is being applied to individual communities or players.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C03R01L03","evidence":"No normalized metric or fairness-across-scales assumption is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C03R01L04","evidence":"No model, policy, intervention, or design transfer across scales is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C03R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C04","confidence":0.99,"reason":"Qualifier deadlines and standings are present, but no collective threshold rule or pivotal contribution structure is established.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C04R01L01","evidence":"No voting, quorum, coalition, dependency, or comparable collective-outcome rule is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C04R01L02","evidence":"No pass/fail or feasibility boundary defined by such a rule is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C04R01L03","evidence":"No complementary contributions are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C04R01L04","evidence":"No hard-to-substitute participant, resource, permission, or jurisdiction is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C04R01L05","evidence":"No divergence between nominal weight and outcome necessity is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C04R01L06","evidence":"No collective threshold that one unit can swing or block is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C04R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"CONTRADICTED","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C05","confidence":0.98,"reason":"The emergent pattern is an unintended harmful scoring tactic that the studio must stop, not a useful pattern to preserve.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C05R01L01","evidence":"The tactic is unintended and its adoption produces disputed rankings; the required outcome is to prevent further adoption and reduce use.","status":"CONTRADICTED"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C05R01L02","evidence":"The tactic spreads through replays, voice channels, creator clips, and social groups, but repeated local interactions generating a useful macro-pattern are not established.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C05R01L03","evidence":"No contextual, emerging, or tacit evidence of benefit is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C05R01L04","evidence":"No need to support the pattern against dissipation or official processes is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C05R01L05","evidence":"No claim is made that formalizing would destroy necessary local judgment or adaptation.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C05R01","route_status":"CONTRADICTED"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C06","confidence":0.99,"reason":"The scenario does not establish a high-dimensional representation, instability, or impractical combinatorial search.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C06R01L01","evidence":"No count of independent variables relative to evidence, compute, attention, or validation budget is given.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C06R01L02","evidence":"No weak, correlated, redundant, leaking, or differently scaled representation axes are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C06R01L03","evidence":"No in-sample fit or out-of-sample instability is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C06R01L04","evidence":"No extrapolation of low-dimensional intuition is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C06R01L05","evidence":"No brute-force search over many independent choices is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C06R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C07","confidence":0.97,"reason":"There is a time-sensitive threat, but the scenario does not establish a distributed mutual-aid coordination structure.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C07R01L01","evidence":"The tactic is spreading and qualifier deadlines make timing consequential, but required distributed action is not explicitly established.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C07R01L02","evidence":"Social-group links and private voice channels are observed, but trust, reciprocity, brokers, or usable relationship-based resources are not established.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C07R01L03","evidence":"No comparison showing formal authority or broadcast to be too slow, generic, or untrusted is provided.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C07R01L04","evidence":"No willing helpers lacking roles, requests, or coordination are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C07R01L05","evidence":"No matching of needs and resources across many actors is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C07R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08","confidence":0.99,"reason":"No proof, exhaustive analysis, incompatibility result, or empty feasible region is stated.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R01L01","evidence":"No proof or exhaustive validated analysis of infeasibility is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R02L01","evidence":"No set of designs and requirements with an integrated-design failure is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R02","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R03L01","evidence":"No exactly-three-guarantee pick-any-two impossibility is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R03","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R04L01","evidence":"No pairwise compatibility and full-set inconsistency analysis is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R04","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R05L01","evidence":"The studio has a required outcome, but no hard constraints are shown to leave an empty feasible region.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R05","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"},{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R06L01","evidence":"No divergent local implementation exceptions resolving a hidden incompatibility are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C08R06","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C09","confidence":0.98,"reason":"No activation-cost pathway analysis or harmful competing pathway acceleration is established.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C09R01L01","evidence":"No repeatable pathway barrier or activation cost is identified as the main delay.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C09R01L02","evidence":"No competing pathways or non-target outcomes from indiscriminate acceleration are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C09R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C10","confidence":0.98,"reason":"The scenario does not establish replicated-state consistency semantics, client invariants, or their missing operational definitions.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C10R01L01","evidence":"The game is multiplayer, but the scenario does not establish multiple actors observing or mutating logically shared state in the specified consistency setting.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C10R01L02","evidence":"No reads from lagging, divergent, reordered, or write-omitting copies are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C10R01L03","evidence":"No delay or partition consistency decision is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C10R01L04","evidence":"No listed client-visible consistency invariant is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C10R01L05","evidence":"No consistency mechanism is advertised, nor is an executable legality definition discussed.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C10R01L06","evidence":"No replica-lag, conflict, repair, or split-brain incident is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C10R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C11","confidence":0.99,"reason":"No dimensions, ratio system, translation across form factors, or size-tuning practice is described.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C11R01L01","evidence":"No relative dimensions communicating design meaning are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C11R01L02","evidence":"No design translation across bodies, devices, sites, products, or fabrication processes is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C11R01L03","evidence":"No hand-tuned sizes or inconsistent local size exceptions are described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C11R01L04","evidence":"No formal ratio system or conflict with content, accessibility, structure, or use is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C11R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]},{"best_route_status":"SATISFIED","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C12","confidence":0.99,"reason":"The scenario explicitly describes an observable spreading tactic, timing-sensitive impacts, varied downstream communities, and a stated desired containment outcome.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C12R01L01","evidence":"The tactic moved from a small group on one regional server into additional communities and public competitive queues.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C12R01L02","evidence":"Telemetry uses first-use timestamps, replay hashes, and social links to distinguish newly adopting clusters from unexposed groups.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C12R01L03","evidence":"Adoption before a roster deadline can produce disputed rankings, while post-season adoption has much less impact.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C12R01L04","evidence":"Remaining communities differ in moderator capacity, youth-league status, championship relevance, and connection to ranked play.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C12R01L05","evidence":"The required outcome is that no additional qualifier community adopts the tactic and use declines where it is established.","status":"SATISFIED"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C12R01","route_status":"SATISFIED"}]},{"best_route_status":"INCOMPLETE","candidate_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C13","confidence":0.98,"reason":"Timing changes competitive impact, but scarcity, durable early binding, compounding early-participation effects, and the stated delay tradeoff are not established.","route_assessments":[{"condition_assessments":[{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C13R01L01","evidence":"The same tactic has greater competitive impact when adopted before a community's roster deadline than after its season closes.","status":"SATISFIED"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C13R01L02","evidence":"No scarce, rivalrous, or path-dependent position that early action can durably bind is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C13R01L03","evidence":"No compounding learning, data, network, standard, brand, reputation, or switching-cost effect from early participation is established.","status":"UNKNOWN"},{"condition_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C13R01L04","evidence":"No tradeoff in which delay preserves information while risking loss of field-shaping opportunity is described.","status":"UNKNOWN"}],"route_id":"E14QF92253D09B02C13R01","route_status":"INCOMPLETE"}]}],"opaque_case_id":"E14QF92253D09B02"}