{"cases":[{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E15A032__DIRECT","case_type":"DIRECT_POSITIVE","domain":"Regional blood-transfusion compatibility operations","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":null,"remedy_leakage_audit":"The scenario describes operational constraints and consequences only; it proposes no corrective action, design, or intervention.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Clinically significant incompatibilities are uncommon and may appear as faint, delayed, or context-dependent irregularities during routine processing."},{"condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"The volume and concurrency of testing prevent technologists from scrutinizing every trace and record continuously; attempts to do so exhaust staff and increase handling errors."},{"condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t3","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"An overlooked incompatibility can seriously harm a patient, while an unfounded concern consumes scarce blood, delays release, and triggers costly investigation."}],"scenario_text":"A regional transfusion center processes several thousand compatibility tests each week while supplying emergency departments, operating rooms, and oncology units. Clinically significant incompatibilities are uncommon. When they occur, the first indication may be a faint reaction in an otherwise ordinary analyzer trace, a discrepancy that appears only after incubation, or a historical detail buried among years of routine records. Technologists cannot scrutinize every trace, instrument state, and patient history at once. Assigning enough staff to watch the entire stream without interruption would be prohibitively expensive, and prolonged concentration has already been associated with slower verification and more specimen-handling mistakes. If an incompatibility goes unnoticed, an unsuitable unit may reach a patient and cause severe injury. Yet treating every weak irregularity as urgent also carries consequences: compatible units are quarantined, emergency release is delayed, scarce products may expire, and senior specialists are pulled into lengthy investigations that often find nothing clinically meaningful.","scenario_title":"Quiet Compatibility Irregularities in a Busy Transfusion Center","vocabulary_separation_audit":"This case uses clinical laboratory language—specimens, incubation, analyzer traces, compatible units, and patient harm—rather than the preservation and cataloging vocabulary used in the transfer cases."},{"alternative_route_blocks":[],"case_id":"E15A032__TRANSFER","case_type":"TRANSFER_POSITIVE","domain":"National film-archive preservation assessment","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":null,"remedy_leakage_audit":"The statement presents the archive's detection problem and competing consequences without suggesting procedures, technologies, staffing changes, or other remedies.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Early deterioration is uncommon, faint, intermittently visible, sometimes revealed only later, and easily blended into ordinary intake work."},{"condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"The collection's scale precludes uninterrupted examination, while exhaustive repeated handling would consume scarce expertise and can damage fragile reels."},{"condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t3","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Missing decay risks irreversible cultural loss, whereas false suspicion consumes testing, cold-storage space, labor, and public-access time."}],"scenario_text":"A national film archive receives tens of thousands of reels from studios, local broadcasters, and private collections. Only a small fraction begin deteriorating during any given intake period. Early changes can be difficult to distinguish from harmless age: a slight odor noticed only when a can is opened, subtle buckling at the edge of a reel, or a chemical shift that becomes clear days after sampling. These clues are scattered through otherwise repetitive cataloging and may not recur during the next handling. Conservators cannot keep every canister under uninterrupted examination. Repeatedly opening and inspecting the entire collection would consume scarce specialist time and could itself damage brittle material. Overlooking genuine decay can allow neighboring reels to be affected and may erase the only surviving copy of a local broadcast. However, incorrectly treating ordinary aging as active deterioration also matters: laboratory tests are commissioned, limited cold-storage bays are occupied, access requests are postponed, and staff spend days relocating material that posed no threat.","scenario_title":"Faint Signs of Decay in a National Film Collection","vocabulary_separation_audit":"The transfer case replaces the direct case's medical setting with cultural preservation and uses distinct language involving reels, canisters, cataloging, chemical decay, cold storage, and archival access."},{"alternative_route_blocks":[{"blocked_by_condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t4","condition_set_id":"B2","how_blocked":"The exercise produces no recurring alarms or persistent status display, and the scenario explicitly states that recognition accuracy remains stable across the short sessions."},{"blocked_by_condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t5","condition_set_id":"B3","how_blocked":"Participants have a defined set of features, fixed review intervals, scheduled recovery periods, and a clear boundary for referring uncertain items."},{"blocked_by_condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t6","condition_set_id":"B4","how_blocked":"No observability or alerting apparatus is present; participants manually examine finite research batches under a structured protocol."}],"case_id":"E15A032__NEAR_MISS","case_type":"ONE_LITERAL_NEAR_MISS","domain":"Non-operational film-preservation training exercise","intended_route_id":"B1","omitted_condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t3","remedy_leakage_audit":"Existing exercise parameters are reported as facts solely to exclude alternative routes; no change, recommendation, or intervention is proposed.","route_evidence":[{"condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t1","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"The target distinctions are rare, faint, intermittent, sometimes disclosed by delayed reference data, and mixed into routine-looking batches."},{"condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t2","intended_status":"SATISFIED","scenario_evidence":"Batch volume and simultaneous presentation make examination of every item at every moment impossible."},{"condition_id":"b003_a09_alr_t3","intended_status":"CONTRADICTED","scenario_evidence":"The exercise explicitly gives both missed targets and false selections no operational, financial, evaluative, or preservation consequence."}],"scenario_text":"A university conservation program runs a rehearsal using disposable film strips manufactured to resemble an archive intake batch. A few strips contain faint, intermittent examples of edge deformation or simulated chemical change; some distinctions become apparent only when reference measurements are released later. The examples are mixed among hundreds of routine-looking strips presented on several tables at once, so no participant can examine every item at every moment. Each participant receives an exact feature list, works in twenty-minute review periods separated by recovery breaks, and refers uncertain examples to the instructor under a stated rule. There are no automated warnings or persistent status panels, and recognition accuracy has remained stable across sessions. Crucially, the strips have no collection value, the exercise produces no retained research data or grades, and nothing is sent into archive operations. Missing a target changes no decision and causes no loss. Marking an ordinary strip is equally consequence-free: it triggers no investigation, consumes no additional material, and affects neither the participant nor any institution.","scenario_title":"Consequence-Free Identification Rehearsal with Replica Film Strips","vocabulary_separation_audit":"The near miss retains the transfer case's film-material vocabulary and rare, ambiguous distinctions while moving to disposable replicas and a non-operational rehearsal; it does not revert to the direct case's clinical terminology."}],"experiment_id":"eoa_inverse_innovation_exp15_route_aware_retrieval40_20260814","sample_id":"E15A032","schema_version":1}