Constitutional Sunsets and Experimental Legislation¶
Ranchordás, S. (2014). Constitutional Sunsets and Experimental Legislation: A Comparative Perspective. Edward Elgar Publishing.
Cited by¶
11 citations across 11 artifacts.
Each citation links to the sentence it supports in the citing article.
Mechanisms¶
- Context-Payload Expiry Policy
- The classic misuse is treating a sunset provision as pure theater: writing an expiry that is auto-renewed without any real re-examination
This sourceDocuments sunset provisions being automatically renewed or reauthorized without meaningful use of evaluation findings.
- The classic misuse is treating a sunset provision as pure theater: writing an expiry that is auto-renewed without any real re-examination
- Override Expiry Workflow
- The framing to borrow is the legislative sunset clause — a provision that lapses unless actively renewed — which works only when renewal demands genuine re-justification rather than a signature.
This sourceDefines sunset legislation as temporary rules that expire after a fixed period unless legislators actively reauthorize them.
- The framing to borrow is the legislative sunset clause — a provision that lapses unless actively renewed — which works only when renewal demands genuine re-justification rather than a signature.
- Policy Review Cycle
- A mid-size nonprofit assigns each policy in its governance manual a review interval — annual for finance and safety policies, every three years for lower-risk administrative ones — often written into the document itself as a sunset provision that forces reaffirmation before the policy is allowed to stand.
This sourceExamines sunset clauses as temporary provisions that expire unless a deliberate continuation decision is made.
- A mid-size nonprofit assigns each policy in its governance manual a review interval — annual for finance and safety policies, every three years for lower-risk administrative ones — often written into the document itself as a sunset provision that forces reaffirmation before the policy is allowed to stand.
- Provisional Role Charter
- … an emergent role coordinable and accountable without committing to permanence: people finally know the role's limits and escalation path, and the sunset date keeps a temporary recognition from silently becoming a fixture — the same logic as a legislative sunset provision that forces a deliberate renewal decision.
This sourceExamines sunset clauses as temporary legal provisions that expire unless lawmakers deliberately renew them.
- … an emergent role coordinable and accountable without committing to permanence: people finally know the role's limits and escalation path, and the sunset date keeps a temporary recognition from silently becoming a fixture — the same logic as a legislative sunset provision that forces a deliberate renewal decision.
- Rationing Relaxation and Sunset Protocol
- A well-formed sunset clause — a provision that terminates a rule automatically unless it is affirmatively reauthorized — is the structural device this protocol operationalizes, and it is the single best defense against emergency powers quietly hardening into infrastructure.
This sourceDefines sunset clauses as provisions under which legislation expires automatically unless lawmakers affirmatively extend or reenact it.
- A well-formed sunset clause — a provision that terminates a rule automatically unless it is affirmatively reauthorized — is the structural device this protocol operationalizes, and it is the single best defense against emergency powers quietly hardening into infrastructure.
- Rotation or Sunset Review
- This is the logic of the sunset clause, a provision that automatically terminates a rule or appointment on a set date unless it is affirmatively renewed
This sourceDescribes sunset clauses as making legislation expire after a predetermined period unless it is affirmatively continued.
- This is the logic of the sunset clause, a provision that automatically terminates a rule or appointment on a set date unless it is affirmatively renewed
- Sunset and Revision Clause
- Its strength is preventing ossification: it drains the swamp of dead-letter provisions, forces rules to periodically re-earn their place, and is especially valuable for powers granted under uncertainty or emergency, where a built-in expiry is a form of institutional humility.
This sourceTreats sunset clauses as temporary legislation that expires after a fixed period, enabling rules to be tested and reconsidered.
- Its strength is preventing ossification: it drains the swamp of dead-letter provisions, forces rules to periodically re-earn their place, and is especially valuable for powers granted under uncertainty or emergency, where a built-in expiry is a form of institutional humility.
- Sunset Clause and Periodic Review
- Its strength is that it makes protection adaptive: force can be reduced as well as increased as conditions change, and a rule must earn its continuation instead of surviving by administrative habit — the discipline of a genuine sunset provision, which lets authority lapse unless renewed.
This sourceThe cited work establishes a genuine sunset provision and lets authority lapse unless renewed.
- Its strength is that it makes protection adaptive: force can be reduced as well as increased as conditions change, and a rule must earn its continuation instead of surviving by administrative habit — the discipline of a genuine sunset provision, which lets authority lapse unless renewed.
- Support Flow Agreement
- The horizon is set as a five-year commitment with a mandatory review and a sunset unless renewed
This sourceDefines a sunset as automatic expiry at a specified time unless the measure is renewed.
- The horizon is set as a five-year commitment with a mandatory review and a sunset unless renewed
- Time-Bounded Veto or Hold
- Its strength is that it is reversible by construction: it inserts an independent check and some breathing room under uncertainty without committing to a permanent veto, and its automatic lapse guarantees that "temporary" stays temporary unless someone actively argues otherwise.
This sourceDescribes sunset provisions as reversible, time-bounded rules that expire automatically unless lawmakers act to continue them.
- Its strength is that it is reversible by construction: it inserts an independent check and some breathing room under uncertainty without committing to a permanent veto, and its automatic lapse guarantees that "temporary" stays temporary unless someone actively argues otherwise.
Verification¶
Does it exist? Confirmed. This work's DOI resolves to a registered record, which fixes its identity. That is all it fixes.
Does it back the claim? Not recorded. Neither this nor any other of the 11 citations of this work carries a recorded support check.
Support is checked per citation rather than per work — the same source can be cited soundly in one article and wrongly in another. Per-citation recording began recently, so a citation with no recorded check is a gap in the record rather than evidence it went unchecked.
See how references were verified.
Links previously used in the corpus¶
Before the registry existed this work was also linked 2 other ways.
- https://www.e-elgar.com/shop/gbp/constitutional-sunsets-and-experimental-legislation-9781783478941.html ×1
- https://www.e-elgar.com/shop/usd/constitutional-sunsets-and-experimental-legislation-9781783478958.html ×1
Registry ID ref:7bda789c5e28 · see in the full table